GAA - Review of appointment
GAA – Review of appointment
If you are unfamiliar with guardianship and administration law, you may want to first read GAA – Guardianship and Administration toolkit.
This fact sheet provides an outline of the law in relation to seeking the review of the appointment of a guardian or administrator. Applications for review are made to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT).
The relevant legislation is the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) (GAA Act).
When will an appointment be reviewed?
The Tribunal must review an appointment:
- At the end of the appointment (in accordance with the order) but at least every 5 years (except in relation to appointment of the Public Trustee or a trustee company): s28 GAA Act.
The Tribunal may review an appointment for a guardian or administrator:
- At any time on its own initiative: s29(a) GAA Act.
- For a guardian (other than restrictive practice matter) on the application of any of the following: s29(b) GAA Act:
- the adult;
- an interested person for the adult;
- the Public Trustee;
- a trustee company under the Trustee Companies Act 1968.
An “interested person” means “a person who has a sufficient and genuine concern for the rights and interests of the other person”: Schedule 4 GAA Act.
Dismissal of application
Under s 47 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act), the Tribunal has a power to dismiss or strike out proceedings it considers are:
- Frivolous, vexatious, or misconceived;
- Lacking in substance; or
- Otherwise an abuse of process.
Please see our Unmeritorious proceedings and conduct causing disadvantage in QCAT fact sheet for more information. However, unlike other applications to QCAT, a guardianship and administration application which has previously been struck out or dismissed will not prevent the same kind of application being made again: s138A GAA Act and s49 of the QCAT Act.
Dismissal can be on the Tribunal’s own initiative or upon the application of an active party.
Alternatives to seeking review
If the issue in question is whether the Adult has capacity for the matter, then it may be more appropriate to seek a declaration of capacity. If it is determined that the Adult has capacity for the matter, then the existing appointment must be revoked: s31(2) GAA Act. See our GAA – Capacity and GAA – End of appointment fact sheets for further information.
Revocation upon review
The Tribunal must revoke the appointment under review unless the Tribunal is satisfied that it would make an appointment for the Adult, as if an application for new appointment had been made: s31(2) GAA Act.
Orders tribunal can make if appointment is still required: s31(3) GAA Act
If the Tribunal is satisfied there are appropriate grounds for an appointment to continue, it may either:
- continue its order making the appointment;
- change the terms of the appointment;
- remove the appointee; and/or
- make a new appointment.
However, the Tribunal may only remove an appointee, other than the Public Guardian if the Tribunal considers:
- The appointee is no longer competent; or
- Another person is more appropriate for the appointment
An appointee is no longer competent if, for example:
- a relevant interest of the adult has not been, or is not being adequately protected; or
- the appointee has neglected the appointee’s duties or abused the appointee’s powers, whether generally or in relation to a specific power; or
- the appointee is an administrator appointed for a matter involving an interest in land and the appointee fails to advise the registrar of titles of the appointment as required under section 21(1); or
- the appointee has otherwise contravened the Act.
The Tribunal may make an order removing the Public Guardian as an appointee if, having regard to the appropriateness considerations, there is an appropriate person available for appointment.
See for example: Re MDC [2004] QGAAT 5 The current administrators were deemed no longer competent as they had entered into conflict transactions without the prior approval of the Tribunal, had not kept appropriate records and had failed to comply with the orders of the Tribunal. The Public Trustee was appointed as no other party was appropriate to assume the responsibilities as administrator.
Re MAF [2008] QGAAT 42 Outlines types of evidence the Tribunal will have regard to when considering a review under s 31. The Tribunal took into account the following conduct of the administrators in revoking their appointment: not adhering to reporting requirements; failure to maintain separation between their financial affairs and those of the Adult’s; significant disagreements between family administrators; and lack of insight into the duties of the administrators.
This resource is current as of 30 June 2023
Disclaimer
The information in this resource is for general information purposes only and should not be relied on as legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact LawRight or another lawyer. LawRight can only give advice to people who are eligible for our services.
GAA - Application for appointment of a Guardian or Administrator
GAA – Application for appointment of a Guardian or Administrator
If you are unfamiliar with guardianship and administration law, you may want to first read the GAA – Guardianship and Administration toolkit.
The following information provides an outline of the law behind making an application to QCAT for the formal appointment of a guardian or administrator or both.
The relevant legislation is the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) (GAA Act).
Who may apply?
The Tribunal may make an appointment on its own initiative, or on the application of the Adult, the Public Guardian or an “interested person”: s12(3) GAA Act.
“Interested person” means “a person who has a sufficient and continuing interest in the other person”: Sch 4 GAA Act.
If necessary, the Tribunal may decide whether a person is an interested person: s126(1) GAA Act.
If the Tribunal decides that a person is not an interested person, that person may ask for the Tribunal’s reasons in writing: s126(2) GAA Act.
Guardian or administrator?
Whether an application is made for a guardian, administrator or both depends upon the type of matter for which substituted decision making for the Adult is needed:
- For personal matters – an application should be made for a guardian; and
- For financial matters – an application should be made for an administrator.
Criteria for appointment – s12(1)
Before making an appointment, the Tribunal must be satisfied that:
- The Adult has impaired capacity for the matter; and
- There is a need for a decision in relation to the matter or the Adult is likely to do something in relation to the matter that involves, or is likely to involve, unreasonable risk to the Adult’s health, welfare or property; and
- Without an appointment –
- the Adult’s needs will not be adequately met; or
- the Adult’s interests will not be adequately protected.
(a) Does the person have “impaired capacity”?
Impaired capacity has a defined meaning under the GAA Act. See our GAA – Capacity fact sheet for a detailed explanation.
(b) Is there a need for a decision to be made OR is the Adult likely to do something that involves, or is likely to involve, unreasonable risk to the Adult’s health, welfare or property?
The Tribunal will not make an appointment unless there is a clear and present need for an appointment. It will not make an appointment for a potential future need or ‘just in case’.
Is the person under 18 years of age?
The Tribunal does have jurisdiction to make an advanced appointment for an individual who has reached the age of 17 ½ years of age, but not 18 years, provided there is a reasonable likelihood that when the individual does reach the age of 18 they will have impaired capacity for the matter. The same criteria under s12 must be met. The advance appointment will not commence until the person has reached 18 years of age (s13 GAA Act).
(c) Is an appointment required to adequately meet the Adult’s needs and protect their interests?
If informal or existing arrangements are currently adequate, then there will be no need to formally appoint a guardian or administrator. For example, consideration should be given to:
- whether the Adult can be supported by other family members, social welfare and care organisations;
- whether adaptive equipment and modification to their living environment is necessary; and
- whether there is an existing enduring power of attorney and whether continuance of the attorney is appropriate.
Some or all of these may ameliorate the need for a formal appointment, particularly of a guardian.
(d) Is appointment consistent with the intent of the Act, general principles and, if applicable, the health principle?
These principles should be applied when exercising a power under the GAA Act. They are set out in full in our fact sheet GAA – Purpose of Act and general principles and general principles.
Types of appointments
Appointments on certain conditions
Appointments can be for a particular matter (for example, a guardian may be appointed to make decisions only about a person’s accommodation) or a number of matters (for example, a guardian may be appointed to make decisions about a person’s accommodation, health care and education) and may be subject to particular conditions imposed upon the appointee: s12(2) GAA Act.
Period of appointment
An appointment can be for a specified length of time, but not longer than 5 years. After 5 years the appointment must be reviewed by the Tribunal: s28 GAA Act.
If the Tribunal does not consider the impaired capacity of the Adult is permanent (for example, an adult may have had a stroke and be expected to make a full recovery), the Tribunal must state in its order when it considers it appropriate for the appointment to be reviewed: s14(5) GAA Act.
Multiple appointments:
Persons can be appointed:
- Solely – for a particular matter or all matters;
- Jointly – co-appointees must make decisions together;
- Jointly and severally – co-appointees can make decisions together or separately;*
- Severally – appointees make decisions about different matters separate from other appointees; or
- Successively – another co-appointee can make decisions when the first appointee is no longer able to do so.
Who may be appointed?
For a guardian: s14(1)(a) GAA Act
- A person who is at least 18 years old and is not a paid carer or health provider for the Adult; or
- the Public Guardian; and
who the Tribunal considers appropriate for appointment, having regard to the matters in s15(1) (“appropriateness considerations” – see below).
For an administrator: s14(1)(b) GAA Act
- A person who is at least 18 years old, not a paid carer or health provider for the Adult, not bankrupt or taking advantage of the laws of bankruptcy as a debtor under the Bankruptcy Act 1966(Cth) or a similar law of a foreign jurisdiction; or
- The Public Trustee or a trustee company under the Trustee Companies Act 1968(Qld); and
- who the Tribunal considers appropriate for appointment, having regard to the matters in s15(1) (“appropriateness considerations” – see below).
Appropriateness considerations: s15(1) GAA Act
In deciding whether a person is appropriate for appointment, the Tribunal must consider the following matters:
- the general principles and whether the person is likely to apply them;
- if the appointment is for a health matter-the health care principle and whether the person is likely to apply it;
- the extent to which the Adult’s and person’s interests are likely to conflict;
- whether the Adult and person are compatible including, for example, whether the person has appropriate communication skills or appropriate cultural or social knowledge or experience, to be compatible with the Adult;
- if more than one person is to be appointed-whether the persons are compatible;
- whether the person would be available and accessible to the Adult;
- the person’s appropriateness and competence to perform functions and exercise powers under an appointment order.
General principles and the health care principle
See our fact sheet GAA – Purpose of Act and general principles.
Conflict
The fact that a person is a relation of the Adult does not, of itself, mean the Adult’s and person’s interests are likely to conflict: s15(2) GAA Act.
The fact a person may be a beneficiary of the Adult’s estate on the Adult’s death does not, of itself, mean the Adult’s and person’s interests are likely to conflict: s15(3) GAA Act.
Appropriateness and competence: s15(4) GAA Act
In determining appropriateness and competence, the Tribunal must have regard to the following:
- the nature and circumstances of any criminal history of the person, including the likelihood the commission of any offence in the criminal history may adversely affect the Adult;
- the nature and circumstances of any refusal of, or removal from, appointment as a guardian, administrator, attorney (ie, power of attorney, or attorney under an advance health directive or similar document under the law of another jurisdiction) or other person making a decision for someone else;
- for proposed administrators who are individuals (i.e. not companies):
- the nature and circumstances of the person having been a bankrupt or taking advantage of the laws of bankruptcy as a debtor under the Bankruptcy Act 1966(Cth) or similar law of foreign jurisdiction;
- the nature and circumstances of a proposed, current or previous arrangement with the person’s creditors under the Bankruptcy Act 1966(Cth) or similar law of foreign jurisdiction;
- the nature and circumstances of a proposed, current or previous external administration of a corporation, partnership or other entity of which the person is or was a director, secretary or partner or in whose management, direction or control the person is or was involved.
Duties of proposed appointees
For proposed guardians and administrators: s16 GAA Act
A person who has agreed to a proposed appointment must advise the Tribunal (before the Tribunal makes an appointment) of:
- Whether he or she:
- is under 18 years; or
- is a paid carer or health provider for the Adult; or
- has any criminal history, whether in Queensland or elsewhere; or
- has been, whether in Queensland or elsewhere, refused, or removed from, appointment as a guardian, administrator, attorney or other person making a decision for someone else; or
- for a proposed appointment as administrator:
- is bankrupt or taking advantage of the laws of bankruptcy as a debtor under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) or a similar law of a foreign jurisdiction; or
- has ever been bankrupt or taken advantage of the laws of bankruptcy as a debtor under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) or a similar law of a foreign jurisdiction; or
- is proposing to make, or has ever made, an arrangement with his or her creditors under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), part 1012 or a similar law of a foreign jurisdiction; or
- is or was a director, secretary or partner, or is or was involved in the management, direction or control of a corporation, partnership or other entity that is proposing to be, is or has been, under external administration.
- Any likely conflict between:
- the duty of the proposed appointee if appointed as guardian or administrator towards the Adult; and
- either:
- the interests of the proposed appointee or a person in a close personal or business relationship with the proposed appointee; or
- another duty of the proposed appointee as guardian or administrator for another person.
For proposed administrators only
A person who agrees to be appointed as administrator must give a financial management plan to the Tribunal for approval: s20 GAA Act.
See “A financial management plan for proposed administrators” on the QCAT website. Guidelines for completing “A financial management plan for proposed administrators” form can be found in the form.
For more information please review:
- Form Number 10 Application for administration/guardianship appointment or review.
- Guardianship for adult fact sheet.
- Administration for adults fact sheet.
This resource is current as of 30 June 2023
Disclaimer
The information in this resource is for general information purposes only and should not be relied on as legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact LawRight or another lawyer. LawRight can only give advice to people who are eligible for our services.
Guardianship and Administration
Guardianship and Administration
Guardianship and administration law governs the situation where an individual is no longer able to make certain personal and financial decisions on their own. In this situation, a substituted decision-maker may be appointed to help the individual with impaired capacity by making these decisions on their behalf
Factsheets
- GAA – Guardianship and Administration toolkit
- GAA – Types of substituted decision making
- GAA – Purpose of Act and general principles
- GAA – Capacity
- GAA – Application for appointment of a Guardian or Administrator
- GAA – Review of appointment
- GAA – Duties of appointees and remedies in case of breach
- GAA – End of appointment
- GAA – Functions and powers of the Tribunal
External Resources
- Public Guardian – The Office of the Public Guardian is an independent body, working to protect the rights and interests of adults who have an impaired capacity to make their own decisions.
- Public Trustee of Queensland – The Public Trustee provides enduring powers of attorney, free wills, investment, executor and financial administration services to Queenslanders.
- Administration for adults– Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal – QCAT can appoint an administrator to assist an adult with impaired decision making capacity by making certain financial and legal decisions on their behalf.
- Guardianship for adults – Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal – QCAT can appoint a guardian to help an adult with impaired decision making capacity by making certain personal and health care decisions on their behalf.
Where to go for help
- LawRight is an independent, not-for-profit, community-based legal organisation that operates a civil law referral service for pro bono legal representation and direct legal services for particular disadvantaged client groups. For more information about the help available, and the process for applying for help, please see the LawRight website at lawright.org.au LawRight’s Court and Tribunal Services provides free legal advice and assistance to self-represented parties throughout the course of their proceedings in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal.
- Aged and Disability Advocacy Australia Inc – ADA Australia is a not-for-profit, independent, community based advocacy service with over 20 years experience in supporting the needs of older people and people with disability in Queensland.
- Caxton Seniors Legal and Support Services – The Seniors Legal and Support Services provide free legal and support services for seniors concerned about elder abuse, mistreatment or financial exploitation. The services are staffed by solicitors and social workers.
- Queensland Advocacy for Inclusion – QAI are an independent advocacy organisation advocating for the protection and advancement of the needs, rights and lives of people with disability in Queensland.
- You may wish to approach a community legal centre for assistance. To find your nearest community legal centre, please visit the Community Legal Centres Queensland website at communitylegalqld.org.au . There are a number of community legal centres throughout Queensland that hold regular advice sessions.
This resource is current as of 30 June 2023
Disclaimer
The information in this resource is for general information purposes only and should not be relied on as legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact LawRight or another lawyer. LawRight can only give advice to people who are eligible for our services.
Witnesses in QCAT
Witnesses in QCAT
This factsheet provides information for people who intend, or are required to, give evidence or produce a document for proceedings before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). It sets out a witness’s rights and obligations under the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act).
An enabling Act may have provisions that supersede the rules stated below. An enabling Act is another Act which gives the Tribunal jurisdiction to hear a particular matter. For example, if the matter relates to guardianship and administration, then the enabling act is the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) (GAA Act).
Notice to attend a hearing
The Tribunal may, of its own initiative or upon application of a party, issue a written notice requiring a person to attend at a stated hearing of a proceeding to give evidence (s 97(1)(a) QCAT Act).
Notice or order to produce documents or things
The Tribunal may, of its own initiative or upon application of a party, issue a written notice requiring a person to produce a stated document or other thing to the Tribunal (s 97(1)(b) QCAT Act).
The Tribunal may also make an order requiring a person to produce a document or thing to the Tribunal or to a party to the proceeding (s 63(1) QCAT Act).
The document or thing stated in the notice or order may be inspected, photographed, photocopied or otherwise recorded by a party to the proceedings unless the Tribunal orders otherwise (Rule 80(3) QCAT Rules).
A person the subject of the order or notice is not required to attend the hearing unless the Tribunal orders otherwise or the person has been given notice under s 97(1)(a) to attend the hearing (Rule 80(2) QCAT Rules).
Witness entitlements
A person who attends a hearing or produces a document in accordance with the written notice issued by the Tribunal under s 97 is entitled to be paid the fees and allowances prescribed by regulation (s 97(4) QCAT Act). See regulations 11 to 16 of the Queensland Civil and Administration Tribunal Regulation 2009 (Qld) for more information.
These fees and allowances are to be paid:
- if the written notice was issued upon application by a party – by the party who made the application; or
- if the written notice was made by the Tribunal on its own initiative – by all of the parties in the proportions decided by the Tribunal (s 97(45) QCAT Act).
Giving evidence
At a hearing, evidence of a witness may be given orally or in writing, and, if the Tribunal directs, on oath or by affidavit (s 95(4) and 98(1)(b) QCAT Act). The Tribunal may also permit a witness to give evidence by tendering a written statement, verified, if the Tribunal directs, by oath (s 57(3) QCAT Act).
However, a child cannot be compelled to take an oath (s 945(6) QCAT Act).
Cross examination
The object of cross-examination is to qualify, weaken or destroy the opponent’s case and, potentially, establish your own case.
Each party must be given a reasonable opportunity to examine, cross-examine and re-examine each witness (s 95(1) QCAT Act).
However, the Tribunal may refuse or limit cross-examination if the Tribunal considers there is already sufficient evidence before the Tribunal about the matter and the evidence has been sufficiently tested by cross-examination (s 95(2)(b) QCAT Act).
In expedited hearings, cross-examination and re-examination of witnesses is at the discretion of the Tribunal, subject to the QCAT Rules (ss 95(2)(c) and 94 QCAT Act).
The Tribunal also has the power to place time limits on the giving of evidence and on the examination, cross-examination and re-examination of witnesses (s 95 (3) QCAT Act).
Tribunal powers in relation to witnesses
The Tribunal can call any person to give evidence on the Tribunal’s own initiative (s 98(1) QCAT Act).
The Tribunal may also:
- examine a witness on oath, or require a witness to give evidence by affidavit.
- examine or cross-examine a witness to the extent the Tribunal considers it appropriate to obtain information relevant to performing its functions in the proceedings,
- compel a witness to answer questions the Tribunal considers relevant to the proceeding (s 98(1) QCAT Act).
However, the Tribunal may not compel a witness to answer a question if the witness has a reasonable excuse for refusing to answer the question, for example, where the answer might incriminate the person (s 98(2) and (3) QCAT Act).
Proceedings where witnesses are not needed
The Tribunal may decide to conduct part or all of the proceeding by solely relying on the documents the parties have lodged with the Tribunal. In those circumstances, witnesses need not appear at the hearing. The parties and their representatives are also excused (s 32 QCAT Act).
Treatment of vulnerable witnesses
Tribunal obligations to conduct proceedings sensitively
The Tribunal has an obligation to take reasonable steps to understand the actions, views and assertions of a witness in the proceeding, having regard to the witness’s age, any disability, and cultural, religious and socioeconomic background (s 29(1)(b) QCAT Act).
The Tribunal must also take all reasonable steps to ensure that each party to a proceeding understands the nature of assertions made in the proceeding and the legal implications of the assertions (s 29(1)(a) QCAT Act). This would include ensuring that each party understands the material evidence being presented by each witness.
The Tribunal is also required to ensure that the conduct of proceedings is responsive to:
- cultural diversity and the needs of a witness who is from another culture, or linguistic background or is an Aboriginal person or Torres Strait Islander;
- the needs of a witness who is a child or a person with impaired capacity or a physical disability (s 29(1)(c) QCAT Act).
See for example, Smith v Condie t/a Listonia Landscaping [2010] QCAT 256.
Interpreters and support people
Unless the Tribunal directs otherwise, a witness to a proceeding may be helped by an interpreter or other person to help the witness to understand the proceeding (s 44 QCAT Act). For example, the witness may be helped by someone with appropriate cultural or social knowledge and experience.
At a private hearing, the Tribunal is required to ask each witness if that witness needs a support person for giving evidence. If the witness confirms that they do need a support person, the Tribunal must allow the support person to attend the hearing with the witness. However, the support person must not represent the party and must not be a party to the proceeding (s 91 QCAT Act).
If the support person is also to be a witness at the hearing, they may be directed to only attend the hearing at certain times (s 91(4) QCAT Act).
Special witnesses
There exist a number of different types of orders that the Tribunal may make where a special witness is giving evidence at a hearing: see s 99 QCAT Act. Section 99 does not apply to guardianship and administration matters: see s 101 GAA Act.
A special witness is a witness who is a child or another person who the Tribunal considers likely, if the person is required to give evidence, to:
- be disadvantaged as a witness because of the person’s mental, intellectual or physical impairment or a relevant matter, such as the person’s age, education, level of understanding, cultural background, relationship with a party to the proceeding or the subject matter of the evidence; or
- suffer severe emotional trauma; or
- be so intimidated as to be disadvantaged as a witness (s 99(4) QCAT Act).
The various orders that the Tribunal may make in relation to a special witness include:
- that only particular people may be present when the special witness gives evidence;
- that only particular people may ask questions of the special witness;
- that the questioning of the special witness must be restricted to a stated time limit;
- that a particular person must be obscured from the view of the special witness while the special witness is giving evidence;
- that a particular person must be excluded from the place where the hearing is held while the special witness is giving evidence;
- that the special witness must give evidence in a place other than where the hearing is held and in the presence of only stated people or with stated people being excluded from the room;
- that a person, including, for example, a support person (see below), must be present while the special witness is giving evidence to give emotional support to the special witness;
- that an audiovisual record of the evidence given by the special witness be made and that the record be viewed and heard at the hearing instead of the special witness giving direct testimony at the hearing (s 99(2) QCAT Act).
A person can apply for one of these orders or they can be made on the Tribunal’s own initiative (s 99(3) QCAT Act).
Non-publication orders
Generally speaking, the QCAT file and hearings are a matter of public record.
A non-publication order prohibits the publication of the contents of a document, evidence given at the Tribunal or information which identifies a person who has appeared or is affected by the proceeding. It may be made on the application of a party or upon the Tribunal’s own initiative (s 66(1) QCAT Act).
The Tribunal may only grant a non-publication order if it considers the order is necessary:
- to avoid interference with the proper administration of justice;
- to avoid endangering the physical or mental health or safety of a person;
- to avoid offending public decency or morality; or
- to avoid the publication of confidential information or other information which would be contrary to the public interest; or
- for any other reason in the interests of justice (s 66(2) QCAT Act).
See for example, Medical Board of Queensland v Mallon [2010] QCAT 311, where the Tribunal granted a non-publication order to protect names of patients, but not the medical practitioner who was the subject of disciplinary proceedings.
Offences and enforcement
Failure to appear
It is an offence for a witness not to attend a Tribunal hearing if they have been issued a notice by the Tribunal under s 97 of the QCAT Act without reasonable excuse (s 214(1) QCAT Act).
If a witness does not attend, then the Tribunal has the power to issue a warrant directing a police officer to bring the person at the time and to the place stated in the warrant to give evidence. The proceedings may be adjourned until then (s 215 QCAT Act). The warrant should be carried out by the police officer in accordance with the requirements under the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000 (Qld), in particular sections 21 (General power to enter to arrest or detain someone or enforce warrant) and 615 (Power to use force against individuals).
A person who fails to appear at a hearing may be the subject of contempt proceedings.
Failure to follow directions
A person appearing as a witness at a hearing of a proceeding must not:
- fail to take an oath when required by the Tribunal; or
- fail, without reasonable excuse, to answer a question the person is required to answer by the Tribunal; or
- fail, without reasonable excuse, to produce a document or other thing the person is required to produce by a notice under section 97 (s 214(2) QCAT Act).
It is a reasonable excuse not to answer a question or produce a document where that information would tend to incriminate the person (s 214(3) QCAT Act). This right is further preserved in section 237(9) of the QCAT Act.
Failure to follow directions is an offence and may result in contempt proceedings.
False and misleading information
Any person, including witnesses, must not say anything or give any document containing information that the person knows to be false or misleading to a Tribunal official. A Tribunal official includes registry staff but does not include a conciliator or mediator (s 216 QCAT Act).
However, a person will not have committed an offence if the person when giving a document tells the official how it is false and misleading and, if the person has or can reasonably obtain the correct information, gives the correct information.
Giving false or misleading information may result in contempt proceedings.
Influencing a witness
It is an offence to improperly influence, or attempt to improperly influence, a witness (s 217 QCAT Act).
Contravention of this provision may result in contempt proceedings.
Contempt of the Tribunal
In addition to the above, a person is in contempt of the Tribunal if they:
- insult a tribunal member, adjudicator, registrar or registry staff member;
- obstruct or assault a person attending a proceeding;
- obstruct or hinder a person from complying with a decision of the tribunal;
- unreasonably interrupt a proceeding or otherwise misbehaves;
- create or continue a disturbance in or near a place where the Tribunal is sitting;
- contravene an undertaking they have given to the Tribunal (s 218(1) QCAT Act).
Children are not in contempt if their actions relate to proceedings which are reviewing a decision about the child (s 218(2) QCAT Act).
The Tribunal has the ability to invoke all the protection, powers, jurisdiction and authority the Supreme Court has in relation to contempt (s 219 QCAT Act). This includes fines, exclusion from the hearing and imprisonment.
This resource is current as of 21 February 2024
Representation in QCAT
Representation in QCAT
This factsheet outlines the rights to legal and other representation before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT).
The following information refers to provisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act). An enabling Act may set out requirements which override these provisions. An enabling Act is another Act which gives the Tribunal jurisdiction to hear a particular matter. For example, if the matter relates to guardianship and administration, then the enabling Act is the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) (GAA Act).
General rules regarding representation
The general rule regarding representation at QCAT is that parties represent themselves unless it would be contrary to the interests of justice (s 43(1) QCAT Act). The rationale for this rule is to avoid unnecessary costs to parties and a legalist approach to proceedings, while ensuring representation is allowed where the interests of justice or natural justice require it.
Under s 43(2) of the QCAT Act, a party to a proceeding may be represented by someone else if:
- The party is a child;
- The party is a person with impaired capacity;
- The proceeding relates to disciplinary action;
- Another Act or the QCAT rules otherwise state that a person may be represented; or
- The party has been given leave by the Tribunal to be represented.
Children and persons with impaired capacity
All parties that are children are entitled to be represented by someone else. A “child” is defined as any individual under the age of 18 years (Schedule 3 QCAT Act).
All parties who are persons with impaired capacity are entitled to be represented by someone else. “Impaired capacity” has the meaning under the GAA Act, which provides that a person has impaired capacity for a matter if they are unable to:
- Understand the nature and effect of decisions about the matter;
- Freely and voluntarily make decisions about the matter; or
- Communicate their decisions in some way (Schedule 4 GAA Act).
Please see our factsheet GAA – Capacity for more information.
Disciplinary action
Where the proceeding relates to disciplinary action, parties are entitled to be represented by someone else. There is no explicit definition of “disciplinary action” in the QCAT Act.
A number of former bodies, which are now subsumed by QCAT, dealt with “disciplinary actions” including:
- Legal Practice Tribunal (see Legal Profession Act 2007);
- Commercial and Consumer Tribunal (see Commercial and Consumer Tribunal Act 2003);
- Teachers Disciplinary Committee (see Education (Queensland College of Teachers) Act 2005);
- A panel of referees convened under the Fire and Rescue Service Act 1990;
- Health Practitioners Tribunal (see Health Practitioners (Professional Standards) Act 1999);
- Legal Practice Tribunal (see Legal Profession Act 2007);
- An appeal tribunal formed under the Local Government Act 1993;
- Nursing Tribunal (see Nursing Act 1992);
- Racing Appeals Tribunal (see Racing Act 2002);
- Surveyors Disciplinary Committee (see Surveyors Act 2003);
- A committee appointed under the Valuers Registration Act 1992;
- Veterinary Tribunal of Queensland (see Veterinary Surgeons Act 1936);* and
- A misconduct tribunal formed under the Misconduct Tribunals Act 1997.*
NB The constituting legislation of the latter two tribunals dealt with disciplinary matters but did not use the term “disciplinary actions”.
Representation with the Tribunal’s leave
The Tribunal may give its permission for a party to be represented. This is at the discretion of the Tribunal; however, in deciding whether to give leave, the Tribunal may consider the circumstances listed at s 43(3) as supporting the giving of leave. These circumstances are:
- The party is a State agency;
- The proceeding is likely to involve complex questions of fact or law;
- Another party to the proceeding is represented in the proceeding; or
- All of the parties have agreed to the party being represented in the proceeding.
See for example, Lida Build Pty Ltd v Miller [2010] QCATA 17, where the President of the Tribunal dismissed the appellant’s application for leave for representation.
A specific form exists to apply for leave to be represented. Please see the QCAT website.
Tribunal appointed representative
The Tribunal may appoint a person to represent an unrepresented party (s 43(6) QCAT Act)
While there is no indication in the Act as to when the Tribunal would do this, it is expected this is done where the interests of justice so require.
Who can be a representative?
Generally speaking, a person can only be represented by a lawyer unless the Tribunal otherwise agrees.
Under s 43(4) of the QCAT Act, a representative of a party to a proceeding must:
- Be an Australian legal practitioner or government legal officer, unless the Tribunal is satisfied the person is an appropriate person to represent the party; and
- Not be disqualified under the QCAT Rules.
An “Australian legal practitioner” is an Australian lawyer who holds a current local practising certificate or a current interstate practising certificate: see s 6(1) Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld).
A “government legal officer” is someone engaged in legal practice for any department or agency of the federal or state governments: see s 12(1) Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld).
Under Rule 57 of the QCAT Rules, a person is disqualified from representing a party to a proceeding if the person:
- Has been the subject of disciplinary action under the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) or equivalent;
- Was found guilty of professional misconduct or unsatisfactory professional conduct; and
- Has not been declared by the President as not being disqualified from representing a party.
This is intended to be a protective power, ensuring that vulnerable parties are not being represented by a person who does not have the capacity or intention to appropriately and adequately represent the party.
Non-Lawyers
A non-lawyer seeking to represent a party must give the Tribunal a certificate of authority from the party if:
- The party is a corporation; or
- The Tribunal has asked for the certificate (s 43(5) QCAT Act).
The Tribunal must be satisfied that a non-lawyer is an appropriate person to represent the party (s 43(4)(b) QCAT Act). There is no indication under the QCAT Act as to who would be an “appropriate person”, and the case law is yet to provide a determination in this regard: Lewis v Queensland Building Services Authority [2009] QCAT 41.
Representation at compulsory conferences and mediation
Where parties to a proceeding are directed to attend a compulsory conference or mediation, the party will either be directed to attend in person or to be represented by a person with authority to settle the dispute (ss 68(1) and 76(1) QCAT Act).
Support people for parties and witnesses
Interpreters are allowed for parties or witnesses who have difficulty understanding English.
A party or a witness may also be helped by another person to understand the proceedings. For example, the other person may be someone with appropriate cultural or social knowledge and experience (s 44 QCAT Act).
Support persons for parties and witnesses must be allowed in private hearings (s 91(3) QCAT Act). However, the support person must not represent the party and must not be a party to the proceeding (s 91(5) QCAT Act).
Costs against representatives
A person representing a party in a proceeding has the same protection and immunity as a legal practitioner appearing for a party in a proceeding before the Supreme Court (s 237(7) QCAT Act). This includes a presumption of immunity from costs orders except in the case of unconscionable conduct by the representative.
However, under the QCAT Act, the Tribunal may award costs against the representative of a party to a proceeding if the representative (rather than the party) is responsible for unnecessarily disadvantaging another party to the proceeding (s 103 QCAT Act). Under s 48(1) of the QCAT Act, unnecessarily disadvantaging another party to a proceeding includes:
- Not complying with a Tribunal order or directions without reasonable excuse;
- Not complying with the QCAT Act, an enabling Act or the QCAT Rules;
- Asking for an adjournment as a result of conduct mentioned in (a) or (b);
- Causing an adjournment;
- Attempting to deceive another party or the Tribunal;
- Vexatiously conducting the proceeding; or
- Failing to attend mediation or a hearing without reasonable excuse.
In such circumstances, the Tribunal may make a costs order requiring the representative to pay a stated amount to the other party as compensation for the unnecessary costs. While QCAT must not award costs against a child, the Tribunal may still order costs against representatives of a child under these provisions (s 101 QCAT Act).
Disclaimer
The information in this resource is for general information purposes only and should not be relied on as legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact LawRight or another lawyer. LawRight can only give advice to people who are eligible for our services.
Hearings in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal
Hearings in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal
This factsheet sets out some rules and procedures which generally apply to Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) hearings. It may be useful for people who are preparing to go to a QCAT hearing and would like some information on what to expect.
The following information refers to provisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act). An enabling Act may set out requirements which override these provisions. An enabling Act is another Act which gives the Tribunal jurisdiction to hear a particular matter. For example, if the matter relates to guardianship and administration, then the enabling Act is the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) (GAA Act).
Who will be at my hearing?
The Tribunal
The Tribunal may comprise of 1 to 3 members depending on the nature of the case. This may include a judicial member, that is, a member who is a Supreme Court or District Court judge. The composition of the Tribunal is carefully selected by the President, taking into account the nature, importance, complexity and special knowledge required for the matter (ss 165 and 167 QCAT Act).
Interpreters and support persons
Interpreters are allowed for parties or witnesses who have trouble understanding English.
A party or a witness may also be helped by another person to help them understand the proceedings. For example, the other person may be someone with appropriate cultural or social knowledge and experience (s 44 QCAT Act).
If the hearing is to be held in private, the Tribunal will allow each party and witnesses a support person to attend the hearing if they require one (s 91 QCAT Act).
Lawyers
As a general rule, parties before QCAT are self-represented unless the interest of justice require otherwise (s 43(1), QCAT Act).
However, the following categories of people are allowed representation as of right:
- Children;
- Persons with impaired capacity; and
- Parties in a disciplinary proceeding.
A person may also be represented if another Act or the QCAT rules state the person may be represented. The Tribunal can also give its permission for a party to be represented (s 43 QCAT Act).
A representative must be a lawyer, unless the Tribunal otherwise agrees (s 43(4) QCAT Act).
See our factsheet Representation in QCAT for more information.
The public
Under s 90 of the QCAT Act, hearings must be held in public. This provision does not apply to guardianship and administration matters, although those matters as a general rule are also to be held in public: see ss 101 and 105 of the GAA Act.
However, a hearing (or part of a hearing) may be held in private if the Tribunal considers it necessary in the following circumstances:
- To avoid interfering with the proper administration of justice;
- To avoid endangering the physical or mental health or safety of a person;
- To avoid offending public decency or morality;
- To avoid the publication of confidential information or information whose publication would be contrary to public interest; or
- For any another reason in the interests of justice (s 90(2) QCAT Act).
What if I don’t go to my hearing?
In the event that a person, who has been given adequate notice of the hearing, fails to turn up or cannot be found after reasonable enquiries have been made, the Tribunal may hear and decide the matter in that person’s absence, even if that person is a party to the matter (s 93 QCAT Act).
What rules apply to my hearing?
Procedure generally
Subject to the QCAT Act, enabling Acts and rules, the procedure for QCAT proceedings are at the discretion of the Tribunal (s 28(1) QCAT Act).
The objects of the QCAT Act include:
- To have the Tribunal deal with matters in a way that is accessible, fair, just, economical, informal and quick (s 3(b) QCAT Act).
The functions of the Tribunal include:
- To encourage the early and economical resolution of disputes including, if appropriate, through alternative dispute resolution processes;
- To ensure proceedings are conducted in an informal way that minimises costs to parties and is as quick as is consistent with achieving justice; and
- To ensure the Tribunal is accessible and responsive to the diverse needs of people who use the Tribunal (s 4 QCAT Act).
In all proceedings, the Tribunal must:
- Act fairly and according to the substantial merits of the case;
- Observe the rules of natural justice;
- Act with as little formality and technicality and with as much speed as the requirements of the QCAT Act, an enabling act or the rules and a proper consideration of the matters before the Tribunal permit;
- Ensure so far as practicable that all relevant material is disclosed to the Tribunal to enable it to decide the proceedings with all the relevant facts;
- Take reasonable steps to ensure each party understands the practices and procedures of the Tribunal, the nature of allegations made in the proceedings and the decision of the Tribunal; and
- Ensure proceedings are responsive to cultural diversity, Aboriginal tradition and Island custom and the needs of a party who is a child or a person with impaired capacity or a physical disability (ss 28 and 29 QCAT Act).
See for example, Thackham v Dunne & Sweeney [2010] QCATA 109.
Giving evidence
The Tribunal is not bound by the rules of evidence and may inform itself in any way it considers appropriate (s 28(3) QCAT Act).
The Tribunal must allow all parties a reasonable opportunity to:
- Call or give evidence;
- Examine, cross-examine and re-examine witnesses; and
- Make submissions to the Tribunal.
However, the Tribunal has a discretion to limit these rights if the Tribunal considers there is already sufficient evidence about the matter before the Tribunal.
Evidence can be given orally or in writing and may be required to be given under oath or by affidavit (s 95 QCAT Act).
You may need to compel witnesses to give evidence to support your case. For more information about witnesses, please see Witnesses in QCAT.
Prohibited conduct
It is important that your conduct in the Tribunal is respectful and does not unnecessarily disadvantage another party to the proceedings. See Unmeritorious proceedings and conduct causing disadvantage in QCAT for information about the risks in conducting your matter in a way that is unfair.
This resource is current as of 21 February 2024
Disclaimer
The information in this resource is for general information purposes only and should not be relied on as legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact LawRight or another lawyer. LawRight can only give advice to people who are eligible for our services.
Costs in QCAT
Costs in QCAT
In matters before a court, the general rule is that the party who is successful is entitled to an order that the unsuccessful party pay their legal costs. Tribunals however, are established to offer an economic process for people to resolve disputes without having to obtain legal representation and incur associated cost risks. As a result, the rules and considerations in relation to tribunal cost orders are different from those that apply at the courts.
The following information refers to provisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act). An enabling Act may set out requirements which override these provisions. An enabling Act is another Act which gives the Tribunal jurisdiction to hear a particular matter. For example, if the matter relates to guardianship and administration, then the enabling Act is the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld).
General rule as to costs
Under s 100 of the QCAT Act, the general rule is for parties to bear their own costs.
However, under s 102, costs can be awarded if the Tribunal finds the interests of justice require it having regard to the following factors:
- Whether a party has acted in a way that unnecessarily disadvantages another party, including (as mentioned in s 48(1), QCAT Act):
- Not complying with a Tribunal order or direction without reasonable excuse; or
- Not complying with this Act, an enabling Act or the rules; or
- Asking for an adjournment as a result of breaches of (a) or (b); or
- Causing an adjournment; or
- Attempting to deceive another party or the Tribunal; or
- Vexatiously conducting proceedings; or
- Failing to attend mediation or the hearing of the proceeding without reasonable excuse.
- The nature and complexity of the dispute;
- The relative strengths of the claim;
- The financial circumstances of the parties;
- For administrative review matters, whether natural justice was afforded by the original decision maker and whether genuine attempts were made to assist the original decision maker; and
- Anything else the Tribunal considers relevant.
See for example, Kehl v Board of Professional Engineers of Queensland [2010] QCATA 77, where the applicant’s application for leave to appeal was misconceived and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondent’s costs in responding to the application.
See also for example, Colmer v Queensland Building Services Authority [2012] QCAT 89, where the applicant had failed to comply with the directions of the Tribunal during the course of the proceeding. He was found to have acted to the disadvantage of the respondent and was ordered to pay the respondent’s costs.
See for example, Ascot v Nursing & Midwifery Board of Australia [2010] QCAT 364 where the Tribunal concluded that the applicant’s case was arguable and the applicant had acted reasonably and not in a way that unnecessarily disadvantaged the respondent so as to justify a costs order being made against the applicant.
See also for example, Gardener & Ors v Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation & Anor [2012] QCAT 62 where, after considering the factors set out in s 48(1) of the QCAT Act, the respondent’s application for costs was dismissed because it had not provided sufficient material to show that the interests of justice required such an order.
Costs against children – s 101 QCAT Act
The Tribunal can never award costs against children. However, this does not prevent a costs order being made against the child’s representative (see below).
Costs in guardianship and administration matters – s 127 Guardianship and Administration Act
Sections 100 (each party bears its own costs) and 102 (costs against a party in the interests of justice) do not apply to guardianship and administration matters (s 101 Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) (GAA Act).
Rather, the general rule provided in s 127 GAA Act states:
- Each party bears its own costs of the proceedings; and
- QCAT may order an applicant to pay an active party’s costs and the costs of the tribunal in exceptional circumstances, for example, if the Tribunal considers the application is frivolous or vexatious.
Costs in minor civil disputes – s 102(2) QCAT Act
In minor civil disputes, costs must be awarded in accordance with the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (QCAT Rules). See rules 83 and 84 for more information.
For examples of what a minor civil dispute is, see the QCAT website. Minor debt claims are a type of minor civil dispute which claim to recover a debt or liquidated demand of money up to $25,000.
Additional costs orders against respondents – rule 85 QCAT rules
An order against a respondent in a proceeding may include an order for the respondent to pay the applicant the prescribed filing fee for lodging the application (see rules 83-85 of the QCAT Rules).
This rule does not apply to minor civil disputes.
Costs where an offer to settle has been rejected – rule 86 QCAT rules
If a party makes an offer to settle which is not accepted by a second party and, in the opinion of QCAT, the decision of QCAT is not more favourable to the second party than the offer, then QCAT may award the first party their reasonable costs incurred in conducting the proceeding after the order was made.
This rule does not apply to minor civil disputes.
Costs orders against non parties
Costs against representatives – s 103, QCAT Act
If the Tribunal considers a representative of a party to a proceeding, rather than the party, is responsible for unnecessarily disadvantaging another party (see above under General rule as to costs), the Tribunal may make a costs order requiring the representative to pay a stated amount to the other party as compensation for unnecessary costs.
However, before such an order is made, the Tribunal must give the representative a reasonable opportunity to be heard in relation to making the order.
While a costs order cannot be made against a child, a costs order can still be made against a child’s representative.
Cost against interveners – s 104 QCAT Act
If the Attorney-General or another person intervenes in proceedings, the Tribunal may order the intervener to pay a stated amount to a party as compensation for all or part of the costs reasonably incurred by the party as a result of the intervention.
See for example, Levy v State of Victoria (1997) 146 ALR 248. The interveners in this case were ordered to pay a proportion of costs based on the increased length of hearing due to their intervention.
Timing of costs orders
Costs can be ordered at any stage of the proceedings (s 106 QCAT Act).
Amount of costs
Under s 107 of the QCAT Act, if the Tribunal makes an order for costs, then it must fix costs if possible. However, if it is not possible to fix costs, the Tribunal may make an order requiring that costs be assessed under the QCAT Rules.
Under rule 87 of the QCAT Rules, costs must be assessed by an assessor appointed by QCAT and QCAT may direct that the assessment be conducted by reference to a court’s scale of costs. Scales of cost can be found in the Schedules to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld).
Appealing a costs order
Costs orders (as distinct from cost-amount decisions) may be appealed:
- If the Tribunal did not include a judicial member: appeal to the appeal division of QCAT with the permission of the Appeal Tribunal (s 142(3) QCAT Act).
- If the Tribunal includes a judicial member: to the Court of Appeal on a question of law as of right, or otherwise with the permission of the Court of Appeal.
Cost-amount decisions, that is decisions about the amount of costs fixed or assessed under s 107 of the QCAT Act, may be appealed to the Court of Appeal on a question of law only and only with permission of the Court of Appeal. It does not matter whether the Tribunal did or did not include a judicial member (s 149(1) QCAT Act).
For more information about appeals, please see our factsheet on Appealing a QCAT decision to the QCAT Appeal Tribunal or Queensland Court of Appeal.
Non-compliance with costs orders
If a costs order is not paid, then the party to whom costs are owed can commence enforcement action by filing it in the relevant court registry and following the enforcement procedure of that court (s 131 QCAT Act). See our factsheet Enforcement of a monetary decision of QCAT for more information.
If costs are awarded before proceedings have ended, the Tribunal may stay proceedings until the costs order has been met (s 108(2) QCAT Act).
Under s 108(3) of the QCAT Act, if a party who has been ordered to pay costs starts another proceeding before the Tribunal, the Tribunal may make an order staying the new proceedings until the costs are paid for the previous proceedings.
A failure to pay the costs order may result in proceedings being stayed indefinitely.
Security for costs
Under s 109 QCAT Act, a party to the proceeding may apply for an order that the other party give security for the first party’s anticipated costs.
The Tribunal can stay the proceedings until the security is given, or dismiss the proceedings or part of the proceedings if security is not given within the period stated in the security order.
The factors that the Tribunal will consider in making a security order are:
- The financial circumstances of the parties;
- The prospects of success or merits of the proceedings against the party applying for the security order;
- The genuineness of proceedings against the party applying for the security order; and
- Anything else the Tribunal considers relevant.
Fees & allowances
Apart from costs orders and security for costs orders, parties to QCAT proceedings may also be required to pay filing fees and witness allowances.
Filing fees – s 38, QCAT Act
Commencing proceedings in QCAT may incur a filing fee. These will be set out in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Regulation 2009 (QCAT Regulations). Please see the QCAT website for more information.
There are no filing fees for applications commenced in the human rights division of QCAT (matters formerly heard in the Guardianship and Administration Tribunal, Children Services Tribunal and the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal).
There are fee waiver or reduction arrangements for people for whom paying the fee will cause financial hardship. Please see the QCAT website for more information.
Witness fees and allowances – s 97 QCAT Act
If you compel a witness to appear at a hearing or produce a document as evidence, then you will be required to pay them an entitlement as set out in the QCAT Regulations.
If the Tribunal calls a witness of its own initiative, then the entitlements of the witness are paid by the parties in proportions decided by the Tribunal.
Disclaimer
The information in this resource is for general information purposes only and should not be relied on as legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact LawRight or another lawyer. LawRight can only give advice to people who are eligible for our services.
Unmeritorious proceedings and conduct causing disadvantage in QCAT
Unmeritorious proceedings and conduct causing disadvantage in QCAT
The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) provides a quick, inexpensive, and informal way of having civil disputes resolved. However, it is still important that people only commence legal action where their case has legal merit, that is, where there is a possibility that they will be successful. It is also important that parties to a proceeding act in a way that is fair and just.
This factsheet outlines some of the risks in commencing proceedings that are unmeritorious or conducting your matter in a way that is unfair.
In this factsheet, “QCAT Act” refers to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld).
Commencing unjustified proceedings – s 47 QCAT Act
QCAT may dismiss or strike out proceedings it considers are:
- Frivolous, vexatious, or misconceived;
- Lacking in substance; or
- Otherwise an abuse of process (s 47(1) QCAT Act).
The Tribunal can also order the party who brought the proceedings to compensate the other party for any reasonable costs, expenses, loss, inconvenience and embarrassment resulting from the proceeding (s 47(2)(c) QCAT Act).
Conduct causing disadvantage – s 48 QCAT Act
QCAT may dismiss or strike out proceedings if it considers that the person who brought the proceeding (the applicant) has acted in a way that unnecessarily disadvantages another party to the proceedings, including by:
- Not complying with an order or direction of QCAT without reasonable excuse;
- Not complying with the QCAT Act, an enabling Act or the QCAT Rules;
- Asking for an adjournment as a result of the above conduct;
- Causing an adjournment;
- Attempting to deceive another party or QCAT;
- Vexatiously conducting the proceeding; or
- Failing to attend mediation or the hearing without reasonable excuse (s 48(1), QCAT Act).
If it is another party, rather than the applicant, who is causing the disadvantage, then QCAT can make its final decision in the applicant’s favour or order that the party causing the disadvantage be removed from the proceeding (s 48(2) QCAT Act).
QCAT may also order the party who caused the disadvantage to compensate the other party for any reasonable costs incurred unnecessarily (s 48(2)(c) QCAT Act).
In making any of these orders, QCAT will consider:
- Whether the party causing disadvantage is familiar with the tribunal’s practices and procedures;
- The party’s capacity to understand, and act on, the tribunal’s orders and directions; and
- Whether the party is deliberately acting to disadvantage other parties (s 48(3) QCAT Act).
See for example, Irvine and Porter v Mermaids Cafe and Bar Pty Ltd and Ingall [2010] QCAT 393, where the Tribunal refused to dismiss proceedings as it was not satisfied that the respondents had been unnecessarily disadvantaged by the non-compliance alleged to have been committed by the applicants with the directions of the Tribunal.
Restrictions on future proceedings – s 49 QCAT Act
If QCAT has ordered that a proceeding be struck out or dismissed under sections 47 or 48 of the QCAT Act, then any future proceedings of the same kind relating to the same matter can only be commenced with the permission of the President or Deputy President of the Tribunal (s 49 QCAT Act).
This provision does not apply to guardianship and administration proceedings (s 138A, Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld)).
Adverse costs orders – s 102 QCAT Act
In QCAT proceedings, the general rule is that each party pays for its own costs of the proceedings (s 100 QCAT Act).
However, QCAT may order a party to pay another party’s costs if the interests of justice require it (s 102 QCAT Act). The factors taken into account by QCAT in making a costs order include:
- Whether a party has acted in a way that unnecessarily disadvantages another party;
- The nature and complexity of the dispute;
- The relative strengths of the claim;
- The financial circumstances of the parties; and
- Anything else the tribunal considers relevant.
Costs may also be awarded if a reasonable offer to settle has been rejected (s 105 QCAT Act).
Please see our factsheet Costs in QCAT for more information.
Contempt proceedings – s 218 QCAT Act
A person is in contempt of the Tribunal if they, among other things:
- Contravene, without reasonable excuse, a non-monetary decision of the Tribunal (s 213 QCAT Act);
- Provide false or misleading information (s 216 QCAT Act);
- Improperly influence a person in relation to that person’s participation in a proceeding (s 217 QCAT Act);
- Insult a tribunal member, adjudicator, registrar or registry staff member;
- Obstruct or assault a person attending a proceeding;
- Obstruct or hinder a person from complying with a decision of the tribunal;
- Unreasonably interrupt a proceeding or otherwise misbehaves;
- Create or continue a disturbance in or near a place where the Tribunal is sitting;
- Contravene an undertaking they have given to the Tribunal (s 218(1) QCAT Act).
If a person is found to be in contempt, QCAT has the same powers as the Supreme Court of Queensland to make orders against that person (s 219(1) QCAT Act). Such orders include issuing fines, excluding the person from the hearing and imprisonment.
This resource is current as of 21 February 2024
Disclaimer
The information in this resource is for general information purposes only and should not be relied on as legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact LawRight or another lawyer. LawRight can only give advice to people who are eligible for our services.
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal - Jurisdiction
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal – Jurisdiction
The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) only has jurisdiction to hear a matter if it is authorised to do so by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act) or another piece of legislation. These other pieces of legislation are often referred to as “enabling Acts”.
When legislation gives authority to QCAT to hear a matter it will specify the “jurisdiction” QCAT must exercise in relation to the matter. QCAT has 3 types of jurisdiction:
- Original jurisdiction;
- Review jurisdiction; and
- Appeal jurisdiction.
Each jurisdiction has its own purpose, rules and procedures and powers.
This fact sheet summarises the three types of jurisdictions conferred on QCAT.
Original Jurisdiction
What does “original jurisdiction” mean?
Original jurisdiction means that QCAT is making a decision on the matter for the first time. In other words, where an application is made to the Tribunal under its original jurisdiction, no other body or person will have previously decided this matter.
When does the Tribunal exercise its original jurisdiction?
QCAT has original jurisdiction for:
- Minor civil disputes; and
- Matters conferred upon it by an enabling Act to decide a matter in the first instance. (s 10 QCAT Act).
Minor civil disputes are defined in s 12 of the QCAT Act. The Tribunal only has power to make orders to the value of $25,000 (or other amount as prescribed by regulation). (s 13(3) QCAT Act).
Examples of original jurisdiction conferred on QCAT by an enabling Act are:
- The Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) which gives QCAT a number of functions including the consideration of applications for appointment of guardians and administrators (s 81 Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld)).
- The Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) which entitles a complainant to require the Human Rights Commissioner to refer a complaint to QCAT if conciliation has failed (s 166 Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld)).
QCAT also exercises original jurisdiction where it is empowered by an enabling Act to review its own decisions. For example:
- The Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) enables parties to apply for review of the appointment of a guardian, the appointment having been made by QCAT in the first instance;
- The Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Queensland empowers QCAT to review decisions where QCAT has decided that grounds for disciplinary action exist.
What are the powers of the Tribunal in exercising original jurisdiction?
The enabling Act conferring original jurisdiction will generally state the Tribunal’s functions in the jurisdiction, which may add to, vary or exclude the functions stated in the QCAT Act (ss 6(3) and 16 QCAT Act).
Who are the parties to a proceeding in the tribunal’s original jurisdiction?
- the applicant; or
- the person the subject of the proceedings, if any; or
- an intervener; or
- a person joined as a party to the proceeding; or
- any other person specified as a party under an enabling Act (s 39 QCAT Act).
Review Jurisdiction
What does “review jurisdiction” mean?
If QCAT has been conferred (or given) review jurisdiction, it means a decision has already been made, generally by a government or statutory agency and QCAT is required to step into the shoes of the original decision-maker and reconsider the decision. This sort of decision making may have previously been referred to as an “appeal”.
The purpose of the review is to ensure that the correct decision was made based on the facts of a case. This is to enhance the quality and consistency of decisions by decision makers and to enhance openness and accountability of public administration (s 3(d) and (e) QCAT Act).
When does the Tribunal exercise its review jurisdiction?
QCAT has review jurisdiction when it is conferred with power to review decisions originally made by another entity (s 17 QCAT Act).
The decision being reviewed is known as the reviewable decision and the entity which originally made the decision is known as the decision maker.
What are the powers of the Tribunal in exercising review jurisdiction?
In exercising review jurisdiction, the Tribunal has the power to:
- confirm or amend the original decision
- substitute its own decision; or
- set aside the decision and return the matter for reconsideration by the original decision-maker with any directions it considers appropriate (s 24 QCAT Act).
The Tribunal may also:
- invite the decision maker to reconsider the decision at any stage of the proceeding (s 23 QCAT Act);
- exercise all the functions of the original decision-maker in relation to the reviewable decision (s 19(c) QCAT Act); and
- exercise the functions conferred upon it by the QCAT Act or the enabling Act (s 19(b) QCAT Act).
How does the Tribunal approach its task of reviewing a decision?
The purpose of the review is to produce the correct or preferable decision. This is done by way of a fresh hearing on the case’s merits (s 20 QCAT Act). A decision must be made in accordance with the QCAT Act and the enabling Act (s 19(1) QCAT Act).
To this end, the original decision-maker is required to assist the Tribunal to the best of their ability, including, for example, providing the Tribunal with a copy of the reasons for decision and any documents in the decision maker’s possession or control that may be relevant to the tribunal’s review of the decision, within 28 days of being given a copy of the application (s 21 QCAT Act).
A detailed consideration of the Tribunal’s approach to reviewing a decision is provided in Queensland Racing Ltd v McMahon [2010] QCATA 73.
How does a review affect the original decision?
The start of proceedings to review a decision does not affect the original decision unless otherwise stated in an enabling Act or unless QCAT specifically makes an order to stay the original decision.
An order to stay the original decision stops it from being implemented. A stay may be ordered upon application by a party or on the Tribunal’s own initiative.
In making a stay order, the Tribunal must have regard to:
- The interests of any person who will be affected by the making of the order or the order not being made (but who may not be given an opportunity to make submissions if that is not practicable).
- Any submission made to the Tribunal by the original decision-maker; and
- The public interest.
The Tribunal may also require an undertaking as to costs or damages, or may impose certain conditions, or may provide for the lifting of the order if stated circumstances occur (s 22 QCAT Act).
Inviting the original decision maker to reconsider the decision
The Tribunal may invite the original decision-maker to reconsider their decision before the review proceedings have been completed. The decision-maker then has 28 days to reconsider their decision and either confirm, amend or substitute their original decision.
The review proceedings will then continue, based on the affirmed, amended or substituted decision, unless the applicant withdraws their application (s 23 QCAT Act).
Who are the parties to a proceeding in the Tribunal’s original jurisdiction?
- The applicant;
- The decision-maker for the reviewable decision (named using their official description, rather than their personal name);
- An intervener;
- A person joined as a party to the proceedings; and
- Any other person specified as a party under an enabling Act (s 40 QCAT Act).
Appeal Jurisdiction
What does “appeal jurisdiction” mean?
The appeal jurisdiction refers to a situation where another entity or QCAT itself has made a decision and there are provisions that allow an appeal to be lodged with the Tribunal.
If the Tribunal is to sit in its appeal jurisdiction, it will usually be constituted by 1, 2 or 3 judicial members (s 166 QCAT Act). This is often referred to as the Appeal Tribunal.
When does the Tribunal exercise its appeal jurisdiction?
The Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear:
- appeals against its own decisions under s 142 of the QCAT Act; and
- appeals against the decisions of other entities under an enabling Act (s 25 QCAT Act).
Generally speaking, a decision of QCAT may be appealed to the Appeal Tribunal under s 142 where:
- A judicial member did not constitute the Tribunal in the proceeding;
- The decision does not relate to a cost-amount decision (an amount ordered to be paid under a costs order); and
- The decision does not relate to the decision of a registrar to accept or reject an application or referral made to the Tribunal.
In certain circumstances it is necessary to get the Appeal Tribunal’s permission to appeal, which is called “getting leave”. The Appeal Tribunal’s leave is required to appeal:
- A minor civil dispute decision;
- An interim or preliminary decision;
- A costs order; and
- An appeal involving a question of fact.
Please see the Appealing a QCAT decision to the QCAT Appeal Tribunal or Queensland Court of Appeal factsheet for more information.
What are the powers of the Tribunal in exercising appeal jurisdiction?
Please see the heading Powers and procedure – Appeals to the Appeal Tribunal under the Appealing a QCAT decision factsheet under for more information.
Who are the parties to a proceeding in the tribunal’s appeal jurisdiction?
The parties to an appeal will be the same as the parties to the original decision.
This resource is current as of 21 February 2024
Disclaimer
The information in this resource is for general information purposes only and should not be relied on as legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact LawRight or another lawyer. LawRight can only give advice to people who are eligible for our services.
QCAT (Queensland Civil & Administrative Tribunal)
QCAT (Queensland Civil & Administrative Tribunal)
For parties with proceedings in QCAT, assistance may be available through LawRight’s Court and Tribunal Services.
How we help people to self-represent
LawRight offers appointments with solicitors who provide advice and assistance with the legal tasks necessary to progress tribunal proceedings, including:
- advice about whether, and how, to commence or respond to proceedings;
- advice about tribunal processes;
- assistance to draft documents such as applications, affidavits, submissions and other tribunal forms;
- assistance with preparing for hearings and appearing in QCAT;
- advice about appealing tribunal decisions; and
- advice about other options for the resolution of disputes.
Who can we help?
LawRight helps people who are involved in, or who are considering commencing legal proceedings in the following QCAT areas:
- Reviews of decisions about:
- Blue Cards
- Disability Worker Screenings
- Child Safety Decisions (however, not proceedings in the Childrens Court)
- Victims Assist Payments
- State Penalties Enforcement Registry (SPER)
- Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA)
- Anti-discrimination
- Right to Information and information privacy
- Disciplinary matters for health practitioners
And some limited scope assistance in:
- Guardianship and administration matters; and
- Appeals and reopenings related to the above matters
Who we can’t help
We cannot help with the following matter types:
- Residential Tenancy disputes
- Body Corporate and Community Management Schemes
- Retail Shop Leases
- Building and Construction
- Trees and Fences
- Manufactured homes or retirement villages
- Legal costs agreements
- Racing or liquor
- Minor civil disputes
How can I apply?
To apply for help from LawRight, please complete the application form here. If you are unable to complete the online form, contact us to discuss alternative arrangements.
Once we receive your application, LawRight staff will check to see if you are eligible. If you are, we will contact you to discuss how we can help.
If you are not eligible for assistance, or we otherwise cannot provide assistance for your matter, you will be notified of our reasons in writing.
If you are unsure whether you are eligible for assistance, you can contact us on (07) 3564 7561 to discuss your legal matter so that we can determine whether you should submit an application for assistance. We will use telephone interpreters when needed. Our lawyers cannot give legal advice over the phone until you have been accepted as a client.
Refer a client to the QCAT Office
If you work for an organisation such as another community legal service or support service and want to refer a client to this service and the client is unable to apply for help themselves via the LawRight Application Form, please complete the Court and Tribunal Services Warm Referral Form and we will be in touch. Please ensure that the matter is one that is expressly stated above in ‘who can we help’.
LawRight office at QCAT
Level 10, 259 Queen Street, Brisbane
P: (07) 3564 7561
E: [email protected]
Office Hours: Monday to Thursday, 9am to 5pm (subject to public health restrictions and staff availability)