Court supervision of cases

Court supervision of cases

The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR) are designed to make civil matters move quickly and efficiently through the court system.

In addition to the UCPR, the Supreme Court has developed two systems that allow for judges to take on a more “hands on” approach to particular cases. These procedures are not available in the District or Magistrates Courts.

This factsheet explains these two systems:

  • Caseflow Management; and the
  • Supervised Case List.

Caseflow Management

The Supreme Court’s Practice Direction on Caseflow Management (PD 17/2012) sets out the Caseflow Management procedures. The Court has also produced a Plain English guide to this Practice Direction.

  • The Supreme Court designates a Caseflow Judge to deal with matters that are on the caseflow management list (paragraph 4.2).
  • Caseflow Review hearings are held on the last Friday of each month that the court sits (paragraph 4.3).
  • The Caseflow Management system relies on email correspondence between the parties and the Registry, and if you receive an Intervention Notice, you are required to give the Court and other party an email address (paragraph 5.2).
  • The Court has decided that if the parties are appropriately progressing their case, they should be ready for trial 180 days after a Notice of Intention to Defend is filed.
  • If a Request for Trial Date has not been filed by this date the parties will receive a “Caseflow Intervention Notice.”
  • If you are the plaintiff it is important that you respond to the Intervention Notice within 28 days, otherwise your matter might be “deemed resolved” (paragraph 5.1).
  • This means that the matter is placed in abeyance, and that the plaintiff will need to seek the leave of the Court to take a step in the proceeding (paragraph 3.3).

You’ve received a Caseflow Intervention Notice – what do you do?

An Intervention Notice basically means that the Court requires the parties to either file a request for trial date, inform the Court if for some reason the matter has been resolved, or explain why the matter is not yet ready for trial and propose a plan to get the matter ready for trial.

If you don’t respond to the Notice, then the Court may list the matter for hearing, and may deem the matter resolved if the parties do not attend (paragraph 5.4).

Think about what steps are needed to progress the matter: are your pleadings in order? Has disclosure been completed? Are any experts reports needed? Have you considered mediation of the case?

You should approach the other side with a proposed order. Paragraph 6.1 of the Practice Direction has a list of the relevant steps that you should consider with the other side.

These include:

  • applying for leave, or giving notice of your intention to take a step in the proceeding;
  • applying to transfer the proceedings to the District or Magistrates Court;
  • amending the pleadings;
  • disclosure;
  • bringing any interlocutory applications;
  • providing for any alternative dispute resolution;
  • any orders for expert evidence;
  • any other directions necessary for the resolution of the dispute; and
  • the filing of a Request for Trial Date or a Discontinuance by a particular date (that should be a day the Court hears Caseflow Review Hearings).

You might also receive a proposed order from the other side.

  • If you can agree with the other side, the proposed orders are emailed to the Associate of the Caseflow Judge, who will then consider the order.
  • If the parties cannot agree then the matter will be listed for hearing before the Caseflow Judge who will make orders.

Once an order is made, you should ensure that you comply with that order.

If you do not comply with a step set out in a Caseflow order then your matter can be deemed resolved.

If you are the plaintiff and you believe that you will be unlikely to comply with the date for taking a step, which if it is not taken will result in the matter being deemed resolved, you should write to the other side setting out:

  1. The fact that you are unlikely to be able to comply with the date under a Caseflow order;
  2. The amendments that you propose to be made to the Caseflow order; and
  3. Propose that the parties contact the relevant Associate and Caseflow Manager, to notify them of these issues, so that the parties are not put to the additional costs of having to re-activate a matter.

Next, you should email the Associate to the Caseflow Judge and the Caseflow Manager by 12 noon on the day before the matter will otherwise be deemed resolved, giving an explanation of what has happened. If you have reached agreement with the other party, you should provide a draft consent order. If you have not reached agreement, you should ask that the matter be listed at the next Caseflow Review hearing (paragraph 6.5).

If you want to progress a matter that has become deemed resolved you need to apply to the Court for the proceeding to be reactivated. You will need to explain to the Court how the proceeding became deemed resolved and outline how you intend to progress the case (paragraph 8).

Supervised Case List

The Supervised Case List exists for cases that are likely to involve a considerable use of court resources either because the trial is likely to take more than five days, or because of the issues involved in the case, it is going to be particularly complicated.

Practice Direction 11 of 2012 sets out the procedures that apply to cases on the Supervised Case List.

Cases on the List are managed with a view to reducing the case down to the key issues.

It involves regular review hearings before a designated Judge, who sets directions for the progress of the matter.

There are three ways that a case can be placed on the List.

  1. A judge of the Supreme Court can refer the matter to the List, either as a result of an application by one of the parties, or by decision of the judge.
  2. A party can apply to the Supervised Case List manager for the matter to be placed on the List.
  3. The Supervised Case List Manager can place a matter on the List.

If an application to have a matter placed on the Supervised Case List is brought, you will receive a Supervised Case List Questionnaire, which is designed to give the Supervising Judge more information about the issues in the case.

The Court will then set regular review hearings at which directions will be given about the progress of the matter.

In these review hearings the Court can consider a broad range of matters. These are set out in paragraphs 16 – 24 of the Practice Direction. These include:

  • whether all the parties required to decide the case are part of the case;
  • the pleadings filed;
  • disclosure;
  • alternative dispute resolution;
  • whether any issues can be determined prior to the trial of the substantive case;
  • expert evidence;
  • trial arrangements (including trial plans, ways of giving evidence, and proof of documents); and
  • the dates for any further reviews.

Commercial List

Complex commercial matters that involve disputes arising out of trade and commerce and that are likely to take more than ten days at trial can be placed on the Supreme or District Court’s Commercial List.

For more information about the Commercial List see:


Representing yourself at trial - Queensland Courts

Representing yourself at trial – Queensland Courts

This factsheet sets out the process for civil trials in the Supreme and District Courts once a matter is ready for hearing. Please see our other factsheets for further information about the earlier steps in the court process.

Court procedure in the Supreme and District Courts is governed by the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR). Any forms referred to in this factsheet can be obtained from the Queensland Courts Website.

Preparation for trial

Evidence

When preparing for trial, you should carefully consider your reasoning, motivations, assertions of fact, legal references and correspondence to ensure your case is strongly argued and supported by evidence.

Consider your Cause of action. Consider if you have pleaded the material facts that you need to establish that Cause of action. Are the inferences that you are asking the court to draw properly made out and supported by the evidence?

Normally, you will have already provided to the other side all the written material, such as documents, witness statements and affidavits, that you intend to rely upon.

You should also keep in mind any pre-trial directions the court has made. This may include providing to the court and the other side a written outline or summary of your case.

Witnesses

You will need to identify what witnesses you intend to call to give evidence for your case. They should be subpoenaed, that is, given a court document which has been filed with the court requiring them to appear at the trial. It is often a good idea to reassure your witnesses and make sure they are aware of what the procedure will be when they come to court to support your argument.

To obtain a subpoena, you must file a Form 44, Request for Subpoena in the Registry together with the fees for the issue of a subpoena and any conduct money to the witness. You can also seek an order that a person attend court to give evidence, that they produce particular documents, or that they both attend at court to give evidence and produce particular documents.

General tips:

  • The trial will usually run from about 10am – 4.30 pm each day, with a lunch break between about 12 – 2, at the judge’s discretion. The judge may also take morning and afternoon breaks.
  • Your trial will be allocated a court room by the court staff. The Daily Law List for matters being heard in the District and Supreme Courts throughout Queensland is available on the Queensland Courts website. The Daily Law List for the Brisbane District and Supreme Courts appears each day in The Courier Mail and is also on display in the foyer of the court building. Ask security if you are not sure where to go – they are always helpful and approachable.
  • Remain courteous at all times. It will be a stressful and frustrating experience, but the judge and court staff will be much more helpful if you are able to remain calm and courteous.
  • If the other party is represented, do not talk to the other party directly – if you want to speak to them, you will need to communicate with them through their solicitor or barrister.
  • Make sure that you have with you:
    • A pad of paper to make notes and write down questions
    • 4 copies of any new affidavits that you have not yet filed
    • 4 copies of any amended pleadings that you may have prepared
    • 4 copies of each of the documents that you want to tender as evidence (4 copies are needed so there is one for you, one for the other party, one for the judge and one for the court file. If there is more than one other party, then you may need more copies so that each party gets a copy).
  • Listen carefully to the judge. The judge is under an obligation to give the parties to a case a fair hearing and an opportunity to present their case. This means that there is some obligation on a trial judge to ensure that a self- represented party has a reasonable opportunity to present their case. However, the judge must remain impartial and cannot give you legal advice. A Judge can provide you with an explanation of the court procedures. Chapter 12 of the Equal Treatment Benchbook of the Supreme Court contains the Guidelines that Supreme Court Judges have published on conducting trials.
  • If your trial is in the courts in Brisbane, Cairns or Townsville, you may find it helpful to contact the Court Network for Humanity. Court Network is a not for profit organisation that coordinates volunteers who are available to support court users. While they do not provide legal advice, they can give you some support on the day. Their contact number is 1800 267 671.
  • There is a difference between making submissions and giving evidence. Evidence is when you or your witnesses tell the court what happened, given under oath or affirmation. Submissions are not given under oath or affirmation, and are usually focused on the legal issues about the case. You can not give evidence unless you have been sworn or affirmed.

On the day of the trial

  1. Arrive early
  2. Consider talking with the other party’s solicitor or barrister about a settlement before the trial starts
  3. Consider asking the other party’s solicitor about who they will be calling as witnesses and how long they expect to take:
    • you may be able to tell your own witnesses what time they are likely to be called to give evidence so that they don’t have to wait around at court all day long.
    • be careful though – if the earlier witnesses don’t take as long as expected, the later witnesses may be called sooner, and the court may issue a warrant for their arrest if they are not ready and waiting.

Start of the trial

  1. If you are the defendant you should sit on the left hand side of the bar table. If you are the plaintiff you should sit on the right hand side of the bar table.
  2. Complete an ‘appearance slip:’ Ask the court staff for one of these when you go into the court room. You will need to insert your name and which party you are (for example, the first defendant)
  3. The judge will enter, and both parties stand and will be asked to ‘announce their appearances.’ The plaintiff or their lawyer will go first. The defendant, or their lawyer will be next. If there are a number of parties and you are, for example, the second defendant, then you will announce your appearance after the first defendant: “Jones, J-O-N-E-S, Robyn, the second defendant. I am self-represented your Honour.”
  4. Procedural matters: Each of the parties may have some procedural ‘house-keeping’ to take care of before the trial can get underway.

This is where you can take the opportunity to file any amended pleadings (if you have one – you are more likely to be allowed to file an amended pleading if you have already given the plaintiff a copy well in advance of the trial) and any applications that need to be dealt with. An application is a request to the court by one of the parties for something, such as a request to strike out paragraphs of the plaintiff’s statement of claim or a request to file new material which has not previously been lodged.

Speak up – remember that you have as much right to be heard as any of the barristers. While the court has to give you a fair hearing to present your case, it is up to you to make the most of your hearing and present your best case.

The progress of the trial

Step 1: Opening statement by the plaintiff which summarises the case you intend to present in court.

Step 2: Evidence of the plaintiff

  1. Witness called and sworn in (that is, swears an oath or makes an affirmation that their evidence will be truthful)
  2. Witness questioned by plaintiff (“examination in chief”)
  3. Witness examined by defendant (“cross examination”)
  4. Witness re-examined by plaintiff
  5. Process repeated with any other witnesses called by the plaintiff

Step 3: Opening statement by the defendant

Step 4: Evidence of the defendant

  1. Witness called and sworn in
  2. Witness questioned by defendant (“examination in chief”)
  3. Witness examined by plaintiff (“cross examination”)
  4. Witness re-examined by defendant
  5. Process repeated with any other witnesses called by the defendant

Step 5: Closing statement by the defendant

Step 6: Closing statement by the plaintiff.

The closing statement should sum up the main arguments and evidence that have been presented to the court.

You will need to be present for the entire duration of the court hearing in order to put your case forward and to respond to what is put by the other parties.

It is likely that you will be required to give oral evidence at the trial. This means that you may be cross examined by the other party’s legal representation. If you are called to give evidence, you may be required to be in the witness box for as little as a few hours or for as long as some days. During that time, you cannot discuss your evidence or issues relating to your evidence with any lawyers or other witnesses.

What can you expect from the solicitor or barrister appearing for the other party?

Solicitors and barristers have a duty to act in their client’s best interests. Therefore, they will:

  • Object to any evidence or submissions you present if unfair to their client, particularly if you make allegations that are unfounded;
  • Question the reliability or character of your witnesses; and
  • Try to put their client’s case in the best light and your case in the worst light (pointing out the negative aspects of your case).

The solicitor and barrister for the other party are not obliged to assist you in the conduct of your case and cannot advise you on the merits of your case. While they may offer to assist you with some procedural matters in order to ensure that their own client’s case is not disadvantaged, you are responsible for running your own case. They cannot advise you of the merits of your case because they are not your solicitor. However, as part of negotiations, they can point out what they believe are the weaknesses of your case.

Solicitors and barristers have a duty to the court to bring to the court’s attention any matter within their knowledge which affects the ability of the court to reach a fair decision and not to mislead the court in any way.

The opening statement

Use your opening statement to tell the judge about what it is that you want to prove, and the evidence that you will be producing to prove it.

This is not the time to persuade the judge that you’re right (that comes later) – it’s the time to let the judge know what evidence you will be producing so that the judge knows what to expect and why it is relevant to your case. Tell the court who you’ll be calling as witnesses.

Your opening statement should also be relevant – think about the key facts that you need to prove, look at your Statement of Claim or Defence – and tell the judge that you are going to prove those key facts.

  • For example: “The plaintiff says that I… but I am going to call Joe Bloggs as a witness who will give evidence to the court about …”

You should not interrupt an opening statement by the other party.

Witnesses

In the opening statement – each party tells the court which witnesses they will be calling.

When you lead your evidence, you will ask the court to call each witness in turn.

The bailiff will go outside the courtroom and call the witness (who should be waiting outside). Only the parties to a case are entitled to be present for the entire hearing. Other witnesses must wait outside the court before they have been called on to give their evidence. Otherwise there is a risk that their evidence will be influenced by what they hear, and the trial judge is likely to put less weight on it.

The witness will enter the courtroom and sit in the witness box and the bailiff will ‘swear in’ the witness.

Evidence in chief

You already know who you are going to call as a witness and what facts you want them to prove to the court. You should prepare your questions for the witnesses before the trial has started. Lots of barristers read questions from a pre-prepared list.

Apart from some very brief preliminary questions, you cannot ‘lead’ your witness. Ask general questions only like “What happened?” and “Where did that occur?” You cannot make specific propositions to the witness about what happened and just ask the witness whether that is correct or not:

  • For example, Patricia, the plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident case is questioning her housemate Alan about an injury. Patricia wants to prove that the accident happened when she was driving to work. Patricia starts off with a couple of leading questions, that establish some very basic initial facts, and that give some context to Alan’s evidence.
You live at 22 Jones Road, Camp Hill?
And that’s the same place that I live isn’t it?
I’m going to ask you some questions about the morning of 3 June 2012.
This is allowed.
However, Patricia can’t continue to ask leading questions such as
That was the day that the Defendant ran into me while I was on my way to work, wasn’t it?
Patricia could ask a question along these lines:
What happened on that morning in our house?
I had breakfast and then I ….
And what did I do then?
The witnesses answers to these questions would seek to show that Patricia left her house to go to work.

The questions must be directly relevant – think about the facts that you need to prove, and ask questions about those things. Once you have what you need in evidence from that witness, you can move on to the next witness.

The witness is not allowed to give evidence that is hearsay. Hearsay can be a complicated area of law. Hearsay is:

  1. evidence of some out of court statement by another person that –
  2. is put in evidence to prove that the statement is true.

For example, Patricia couldn’t introduce evidence from Alan that immediately after the accident she rang him up and said “I’ve been run into” to prove that she was involved in an accident. She could prove that she was in an accident by more direct evidence, eg evidence from the police who attended the scene, expert evidence about how the accident happened, evidence from the doctors who treated her at the hospital.

While an out of court statement can’t be relied on to prove that the statement is true, it can be used for some other purpose.

For example: Bob is suing Jane for misrepresentation. Bob says that Jane told him before he made a contract with a company she controlled, that she had lots of really wealthy friends, and that for an outlay of $10,000, Bob would make millions. Jane has since relocated to Taiwan.

Bob can introduce these representations – because he’s not using them to show that what Jane told him (that she has lots of really wealthy friends, or that he would make millions of dollars from the contract) is true, he is using this evidence to show that Jane made the representations to him. Bob’s evidence is not hearsay.

The day after this contract was made, Bob tells his friend Roger about his conversation with Jane. Roger’s evidence of what Bob told him would be hearsay. It would be being used to tell the court that Jane had given Bob those representations, which Roger is unable to confirm. He only believes it because Bob told him so.

Unless the witness is an expert, they are not allowed to give ‘opinions’ about things. They can only talk about events that actually occurred.

If you want to ask a witness to comment on a particular document (for example, you may want a witness to comment on the statutory declaration that they signed):

  • Tell the judge that you want to show the witness a document – the bailiff will take the document from you and hand it to the witness
  • Ask the witness about what the document is, whether they can recall when, why or how the document was created
  • When you are finished asking the witness about the document, tell the judge that you would like the document “tendered as an exhibit.”

If you want to object to a question that has been asked, stand up straight away and say “Your Honour, I would like to object to that question because…” The Judge may ask you to clarify your reasons for objecting, and may then ask the other party for their views. The Judge will then rule on your objection

You should have a good reason for objecting. It is not enough to say that you disagree with the question or the answer it will produce. Grounds for objecting include lack of relevance, hearsay, non-expert opinion.

Trials can move very quickly. It’s important that you pay close attention to the questions that the other party asks – and also to the answers that are given.

Cross examination

Once the examination in chief is complete, the other party is then able to cross examine the witness.

Mastering cross examination is difficult, even for many lawyers.

Despite what you may have seen on television, cross examination is not an opportunity for bullying or arguing with the witnesses, ending in a teary admission that their entire evidence was lies.

If the witness is not going to say anything helpful to your case, it is usually best to not ask them any questions, unless you have to. By not asking questions, you will deny the witness the opportunity to build the other sides’ case.

A key principle in cross examination is known by lawyers as “the rule in Browne v Dunn.” This means that if you intend, in your summing up, to tell the court that what a witness has said was X, whereas what actually happened was Y, you must “put” that to the witness, and give that witness an opportunity to respond to your case.

For example, in a motor vehicle accident case, the Plaintiff says that he was driving along a single lane road and that the Defendant collided with him. The Defendant’s case is that the Plaintiff was speeding – the Defendant must “put” to the Plaintiff that the Plaintiff was speeding at the time of the accident.

You do this by asking the other party “I put it to you that ……”

In a medical negligence case, the plaintiff is claiming that he received extensive care from his mother. The defence denies that this took place, and their investigators have uncovered that she was working at the time. When cross examining the mother, the defence must “put” to the mother that she was in fact working at the time.

If used effectively – cross examination can be used to undermine the other party’s case.

Unlike evidence-in-chief, in cross examination you can ask leading questions. If you think the witness gave evidence that was untrue or misleading, you can say: “Isn’t it true that…” Some lawyers believe that you should only ask leading questions in cross examination.

Try and have any important questions prepared. Before the trial, think about what you want to get out of the cross examination. You can often prepare questions in advance of the trial date. Write down further questions that you think of while they are giving their evidence in chief.

Looking at the other party’s court documents and affidavits you will know what facts they are trying to establish. Think about how you can best respond to the evidence.

Take your time – if you need to check your documents to make sure you have asked all of the questions that you need to ask, then do so. The barrister for the other party will be taking their time to make sure they have covered everything with the witness, so you can do the same.

Many people may find being cross-examined an unpleasant and stressful experience.

Re-examination

After cross examination the other party can revisit any of the issues by asking the witness a few more questions. You can revisit issues that the witness has been cross-examined about if you think you need to clarify exactly what their evidence is about on a particular point.

Summing up

Each of the parties will then be given a chance to make closing submissions.

This is your chance to reiterate your case and persuade the judge that you are right and that you have either successfully proven your case, or defended the case against you.

Judgment

The judge will then leave the courtroom to ‘deliberate’ and make a decision. That is the end of the trial.

The judge will either hand down his decision on the day, or the matter will be adjourned. If that happens, the judge’s associate will call you when the judge has made a decision and will tell you what date and time the judge will deliver the decision. You will need to return to the court on that day to obtain the judgment.

Costs

When the judge hands down the decision, be ready to make submissions on costs, that is, whether the losing party should be expected to pay for the successful party’s legal costs. You can have written submissions prepared for if you win or lose.

For example, if you are successful, you could say to the court that you should be entitled to your costs because of Rule 681 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1991 which states that “costs …follow the event”. It may also be relevant to show how the other party caused delay or additional expense in preparing the matter for trial or unreasonably rejected offers of settlement.

If you are unsuccessful, you would need to make submissions on why you should not have to pay the successful party’s costs. Again, your conduct and their conduct throughout the litigation will be relevant.

Observing the court process

You may gain a better understanding of the hearing process by going to court and observing a matter prior to the commencement of your own case.

If you are in the Brisbane, Townsville or Cairns courts, you may be able to arrange a visit to the court building beforehand with the Court Network for Humanity to familiarise yourself with the building. You can contact the Court Network by telephone at 1800 267 671.

Most court hearings are open to members of the public. The Daily Law List contains a list of each matter that the courts are hearing on any given day. If you do decide to go to court to watch a hearing, dress smartly and behave in a respectful and courteous fashion.


Hearings in court - commonly used words

Hearings in court – commonly used words

General Legal Terms

Adjournment: When a hearing is delayed until a later date. An adjournment will not automatically be granted.

Affidavit: A written statement of facts made under oath or affirmed before a notary public, justice of the peace, lawyer or other authorised officer. An affidavit can be used to support an application or can be used as evidence in court.

Affirmation: To confirm a legal decision, particularly (of an appeal court) to confirm a judgment made in a lower court.

Alternative dispute resolution: Various methods of resolving civil disputes otherwise than through the normal trial process. The court will encourage the parties to use an alternative dispute resolution procedure if the court considers this appropriate and should facilitate the use of such procedures.

Appearance: Coming to the court as a party, either in person or through a representative (i.e. a barrister). The judge will often state “I will take appearances” at the start of a hearing. The word “appearance” may also refer to a Notice of Intention to Defend (see below).

Arbitration: In arbitration, a dispute between two or more people will be decided by an impartial third party (called an arbitrator). Arbitration occurs outside the court process but is still binding on the parties. Arbitration may be agreed to by the parties, may be required by a provision in a contract for settling disputes, or may be provided for under statute.

Barrister: A legal practitioner specialising in court work, admitted to plead at the Bar.

Cause of action: A cause of action is the “legal wrong” that entitles a party brings a case to court, e.g. negligence, breach of contract, defamation. Without a cause of action you should not commence a court case because you cannot be successful.

Callover: A court procedure which involves numerous cases being listed before a judge or registrar and each being given a chance to advise the court of the progress of the case. As part of this process, the names of the parties involved in the case are called out. Those parties are then able to directly address the judge or registrar. It is then up to the judge or registrar to determine whether the case is ready for hearing and to provide parties with a hearing date.

Civil law: A broad division of the law that encompasses, among other things, the law governing business, contracts, estates, domestic (family) relations, accidents, negligence. Civil law is to be distinguished from criminal law (see below).

Conciliation: A process where an independent person meets with parties to a dispute in an attempt to assist in them coming to an agreement. The outcomes of a conciliation process will not be legally binding on the parties.

Contempt of court: Contempt of court is an offence resulting out of disturbance to the orderly administration of justice. Contempt typically occurs in one of two ways:

  1. Where a person is rude or disrespectful to a judge or causes a disturbance in the courtroom;
  2. Where a party wilfully fails to obey an order of the court.

Costs: The legal fees or expenses of a party to matter in the court. A court may order one party to pay all or part the costs of another party.

Costs order: When you engage a solicitor, you pay for their services in the same way that you pay for a plumber’s or computer repairer’s services. When the legal work includes litigation – taking or defending court action – then legal costs can be substantial, because there are many steps involved such as drafting the court documents, disclosing evidence and then the costs of the trial. In our legal system, the usual rule is that “costs follow the event” which means that the losing party pays the costs of the winning party. The law gives the judge the power to decide and order which party pays the costs, and judges can order a party that delays court proceedings or who unduly increases costs to pay them.

Court: A body established by law for the administration of justice by judges or magistrates.

Damages: Monetary compensation ordered by a court in response to a wrong committed by one party against another.

Debt or liquidated demand: A liquidated demand is a claim for a fixed amount, usually under a contract.

Declaration: A written statement made a person (the declarant). If the statement contained in a declaration is knowingly false, the declarant may be liable to punishment for perjury.

Defence: The case presented by or on behalf of the party being accused of a crime or sued in a civil lawsuit.

Defendant: The party sued in a civil lawsuit or the charged with a crime. In some types of cases (such as divorce proceedings) a defendant may be called a respondent.

Default judgment: A judgment that a court makes when a defendant who has been properly served with a claim and statement of claim fails to file a notice of intention to defend and a defence within 20 days.

Directions: Instructions given by a judge before the trial or hearing to assist the parties to properly prepare for the hearing.

Disclosure: The process by which parties to civil litigation are required to provide the other party access to any documents that may be relevant to the particular case.

Discontinuance: Occurs when a party who has started legal proceedings elects to abandon proceedings.

Evidence material: Evidence material, such as the statements of witnesses or contents of documents, that can be used by a party to support a claim made in court. For further detail see our factsheet Evidence and proof in civil proceedings.

Hearing: A proceeding conducted by the court to resolve issues or fact and/or law. The hearing allows the parties to present evidence in support of their claim.

Injunction: A court order forcing a person to do, or refrain from, doing something.

Injury: Infringement of a right or actual harm caused to people or property.

Interlocutory: An interlocutory matter is one that is dealt with between the filing of the application and the giving of the final hearing and/or decision.

Interlocutory hearing: An interlocutory hearing is any court hearing that deals with a procedural issue, and is different from a trial that finally decides the dispute between the parties.

Interlocutory steps: Interlocutory steps are those steps in the civil court cases that take place between the initial filing and then the final determination of the case.

Interrogatories: A series of written questions which one party may ask another party prior to the hearing. Interrogatories are designed to obtain admissions to assist the party asking the questions.

Judgment: The final order or set of orders made by a judge after a court hearing.

Judicial discretion: The right of a judge to make a choice, for example, deciding whether or not to grant an adjournment; deciding how much compensation to award to the party that wins a case.

Jurisdiction: The authority of a court to decide matters brought before it.

Lawyer: A general term for a person who practises law.

Leave: Permission to do something (when given by a court).

Legislation: An act of parliament; a statute.

Limitation date: A limitation period is a period of time within which a cause of action must commence in court or a step be taken in proceedings. The limitation date is the last day for commencing a court action or taking a necessary step in an existing action. Limitation periods vary between causes of action and between jurisdictions. If you have not commenced the action or have not taken the next step in the proceedings before the limitation date expires you may lose your opportunity to make a claim.

Loss: The fact or process of losing something.

Matter: A particular legal proceeding.

McKenzie friend: A “McKenzie friend” is a lay person who is entitled to assist a party present their case in court and sit with you at the bar table. A McKenzie friend is not a lawyer. You do not automatically have the right to have a McKenzie friend appear with you at court, you need to ask the leave of the court.

Mediation: A process in which an impartial third party assists the parties to a dispute in an attempt to bring about an agreed settlement or compromise.

Notice of intention to defend: In civil proceedings, written notice that a person intends to defend against the claim of another party. It must be filed with a defence.

Oath: A promise to tell the truth in court proceedings. A person will be subject to prosecution for the crime of perjury if he or she knowingly lies in a statement made under oath.

Obiter dictum: A statement by a judge made during a judgement which does not form part of the central reasons for the decision.

Order: A demand of the court. If you fail to comply with a court’s order you may be held in contempt of court (see above).

Originating process: A document that starts a proceeding in court.

Particulars: Details of an allegation of fact made by either side in civil proceedings.

Plaintiff: The party who initiates a lawsuit.

Pleadings: Written statements that define the issues to be decided in a case.

Precedents: Previous judgments of the courts relating to the same or similar issues. The term may also refer to examples of forms that must be filed at various stages of a proceeding.

Prosecutor: Generic term for the government’s attorney in a criminal case.

Prima facie case: A case which is supported with enough evidence that it can be said to be established on a preliminary basis. A prima facie case may then be dispelled by the evidence of the other party.

Ratio decidenti: The legal reasoning on which a judgement is based.

Remedy: An order made by a court to make up for a wrong. A remedy will often involve monetary compensation.

Service (serve): The sending or giving of documents to the other party to a case in accordance. The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 may set down a particular method by which service must take place.

Standing: The right to bring an action.

Statement of claim: A document that sets out the facts that support the claims made in the case.

Solicitor: A legal practitioner admitted to practice.

Statute: Legislation; an act of parliament.

Subpoena: A document issued in a legal proceeding requiring a person to give evidence or to produce documents to the court at a certain place and time.

Submission: A proposal or application submitted for consideration.

Summons: A document issued by a court directing a person to appear before it.

Tribunal: A body that exercises jurisdiction over a particular issue under powers conferred by legislation.

Unliquidated damages: Unliquidated damages are for an amount that the court must assess, for example, if you are injured in a motor vehicle accident, the court must still assess the compensation you are entitled to.

Without prejudice: A statement or offer made on the basis that it will not affect a person’s legal rights in later court action.

Writ: A written court order to do or refrain from doing something.

People in the court room

Agent: An independent person or company with authority to act on behalf of another.

Appellant: A person that starts an appeal in a court. Applicants, appellants, respondents, defendants etc. are generally called “parties”.

Applicant: A person who applies to the court to start a legal proceeding.

Associate: A judge’s personal legal assistant.

Bailiff: A court official, who keeps order in the courtroom and handles various errands for the judge and associate.

Barrister: A lawyer who presents cases in courts.

Counsel: A barrister.

Crown prosecutor: Legal representative of the government who institutes criminal proceedings against an accused person.

Defendant: Person brought to court to answer claims made by a plaintiff or to be charged with a criminal offence.

Litigants: People or companies who are parties to a dispute before a court.

Litigants in person: People who are a party to a dispute before the court, who have no legal representative and are conducting the matter on their own behalf (sometimes called self represented litigants).

Parties: People, organisations or corporations involved in a court case.

Plaintiff: A party who initiates a civil action.

Respondent: The person, organisation or corporation against whom legal proceedings have been started by the applicant.

Solicitor: A person who is qualified to perform legal services. Solicitors may appear on behalf of parties in court proceedings (though, in higher courts this is more commonly done by barristers).


Hearings in Queensland Courts - twelve tips (Spanish Translation)

Hearings in Queensland Courts - twelve tips (Spanish Translation)

Litigación civil: Doce consejos para sobrevivir a un juicio.

Introducción

Esta hoja informativa le proporcionará la información general necesaria en un juicio civil.

  1. Es necesario conocer el asunto del juicio. Si la otra parte ha puesto la demanda, lea la información con detenimiento. ¿Es un juicio o un auto interlocutorio? ¿Ha recibido la demanda? ¿Es la primera sesión del juicio?
  2. La demanda enumera las decisiones que la otra parte quiere que tome el juez. Debe leerlas con detenimiento. Si está de acuerdo con la demanda se puede formular un decreto de consentimiento. De esta manera se ahorra tiempo al tribunal, dinero para las partes y el estrés que un juicio conlleva.
  3. ¿Puede comparecer al juicio? La demanda informa sobre dónde se celebrará el juicio. El juzgado asume que las partes toman los pasos necesarios para avanzar en el caso. Si usted ha recibido la demanda y no comparece al juicio, el proceso puede continuar sin su presencia y puede perder el juicio. En algunos casos, se puede pedir a la secretaría del tribunal que se organice la comparecencia por teléfono.
  4. Si requiere un aplazamiento, debería preguntar a la otra parte si está de acuerdo. Si el juicio es en A District Court o The Supreme Court, hay que tener en cuenta que se mostrarán reticentes a la hora de aplazar un juicio, especialmente si la fecha se estableció hace tiempo.
  5. Debería respaldar la demanda de un aplazamiento con los documentos pertinentes. Si pide un aplazamiento por razones de salud debe adquirir una declaración jurada o como mínimo un certificado de su médico de cabecera que explique por qué no puede comparecer o participar en el juicio. No se debe nunca asumir que se otorgará un aplazamiento simplemente porque se ha enviado un fax o un escrito al juzgado.
  6. Si va a formular un escrito para responder a la demanda, es necesario presentar una copia sellada de este a la otra parte al menos dos días hábiles antes de que se celebrara el juicio.
  7. Tenga en cuenta que puede asistir al juicio acompañado. Un juicio, para la mayoría de personas, es una experiencia angustiosa y se puede disminuir el nivel de estrés yendo con alguien. A pesar de que solamente un abogado tiene el derecho de representarle en un juicio se permite que otra persona, denominado un “McKenzie friend” le proporcione ayuda.
  8. Debería sentarse en el lado izquierdo del Bar (cuando se entra en la sala)
  9. A veces, cuando se acude al juzgado, el abogado de la otra parte se le acercará con un “decreto de consentimiento” que ha formulado. Aunque esta situación puede intimidar a muchas personas que se representan a sí mismos, es un procedimiento normal. Si necesita tiempo para leer los documentos, informe al juez, y entonces este puede aplazar el juicio hasta más tarde en el día.
  10. Antes de que termine el juicio, asegúrese de que conoce:
    1. ¿Qué órdenes se dictaron?
    2. ¿Cuál es su próximo paso y cuando lo tiene que tomar?
    3. ¿Cuál es el próximo paso de la otra parte y cuándo lo tiene que tomar?Apunte la información. Si no se entiende alguna de las órdenes que se dictaron, pídale al juez que se lo explique.
  11. Después del juicio una de las partes (normalmente el demandante) formula un proyecto de orden (Form 59) que será rellenado y sellado dentro del juzgado.
  12. The Court Network for Humanity, es una asociación sin fines de lucro que ayuda a usuarios de juzgados en numerosos juzgados de Queensland y podría ayudarle o remitirle a otra asociación. Número de contacto: 1800 267 671.

Entre las hojas informativas relacionadas con ésta se encuentra la hoja sobre ‘protocolo en el juzgado’ y la hoja sobre ‘términos usados en un proceso judicial’.


Hearings in Queensland Courts - twelve tips

Hearings in Queensland Courts - twelve tips

This factsheet is designed to give you some basic information to assist you to prepare for a court hearing in a civil case.

Twelve Tips

1. Know what your hearing is about.

  • If the other party have brought the application, read through their material carefully.
  • Is it a trial, or an interlocutory hearing?
  • If you have received an originating application, is it the first hearing?

2. Read the orders listed on the application carefully.

  • The application will list the orders that the other party is asking the court to make.
  • If you agree with the orders they seek, then you may be able to come to an agreement with the other party so that "consent orders" can be made.
  • This saves the court time, can save the parties' costs, and can relieve the stress of appearing in court.

3. Can you attend the hearing?

  • The Application will state which court house the hearing will be held in.
  • The court expects the parties to proceedings to progress their case.
  • If you've been properly served with the application, and you do not turn up to the hearing, the court may still be able to deal with the matter, and make orders against you.
  • In some cases, you can approach the court registry to make arrangements to appear by telephone.

4. Applying for an adjournment?

  • If you have to apply for an adjournment, you should approach the other side and see if they will consent to an adjournment.
  • If your hearing is a trial in the District or Supreme Courts, be aware that the courts can be reluctant to adjourn trials, especially if they have been set down for some time.

5. You should make any application for an adjournment as strong as possible.

  • If you are asking for an adjournment on health grounds, you should have an affidavit or at least a detailed medical certificate from your doctor setting out why you cannot attend or participate in the hearing, what treatment you are receiving and when you will be able to participate in a hearing.
  • Never assume that an adjournment will be granted if you simply fax or write to the court.

6. Filing in response

  • If you are going to be filing anything in response to the application, make sure you file and serve a sealed copy of your material on the other party at least two business days before the hearing.

7. Consider taking a support person to the hearing.

  • Being in court is a stressful experience for many people and it can be helpful to have someone to attend the hearing with you.
  • While only a lawyer can represent a party in court, the court can give leave to allow a non-lawyer, called a "McKenzie friend" to assist you in the court.

8. Positioning in courtroom.

  • You should usually sit at the left hand side of the bar table (as you walk in to the court).

9. Court matters at hearings.

  • Sometimes, when you arrive at a hearing, the other party's lawyer might approach you with a "consent order" or with submissions that they have drafted.
  • While this can be intimidating for many self-represented parties, it is often how court matters are conducted by lawyers.
  • If you need time to read through the documents, tell the Judge, and your matter may be able to be dealt with later in the day.

10. Before you leave a hearing make sure that you know:

a. What orders were made?
b. What is your next step, and when do you have to take it?
c. What is the other parties' step and when do they have to take that?
  • Take notes. If you're uncertain about what orders have been made, ask the judge to explain.

11. After the hearing.

  • After the hearing it is usual for one of the parties (usually the applicant) to prepare a Draft Order (Form 59, available here) that gets filed and sealed by the court.

12. Assistance for appearing in court.

  • If you are appearing in court, the Court Network for Humanity, a not for profit organisation that assists court users in a number of Queensland courts might be able to assist or refer you.
  • The Court Network for Humanity can be contacted by telephone at 1800 267 671.

More information

You can also see our factsheets on Court etiquette and Hearings in court - commonly used words.


Dealing with lawyers on the other side of litigation

Dealing with lawyers on the other side of litigation

A common concern of self-represented parties in civil cases is how to deal with lawyers representing the other party. This factsheet sets out some tips and suggestions for dealing with a represented party.

  1. If the other party is represented by a lawyer, deal with the lawyer rather than the other party. If the other party contacts you personally, you should always speak to the other party’s lawyer to tell them that their client has contacted you directly.
  2. Bear in mind that the lawyer is only representing the other party in your case. As much as possible, you should try and separate your feelings about the other party from your dealings with the lawyer.
  3. The other lawyer cannot give you legal advice as they are not acting for you. They may sometimes assist you with a procedural step, in the interests of progressing their client’s case, or they might during a negotiation tell you why they think your case is weak, but they are not able to give you legal advice.
  4. Keep your phone conversations and letters to the lawyer neutral and on point. Do not get into arguments or accuse the lawyer of misconduct. It doesn’t help your case and it may weaken your credibility before the judge.
  5. Lawyers take accusations of improper conduct very seriously and you need very clear evidence that establishes that the lawyer has acted improperly. Acting in their client’s (and against your) interests, is not enough to establish misconduct.
  6. A good rule of thumb is that you should not write anything to the other side that you would not be comfortable with the judge reading. Even if you are writing on a “without prejudice” basis, this can become relevant to the judge’s decision about costs.
  7. Consider what battles you are going to fight. Litigation can be a long and drawn out process. You don’t need to take issue with everything that the lawyers for the other party do (or don’t do). Taking this approach to litigation can be counterproductive. For example:

    Lisa is being sued by her former lawyers for payment of her bill. Lisa has brought a counterclaim arguing her lawyers were negligent. On 1 February, the Supreme Court makes orders requiring Lisa to file an Amended Defence and Counterclaim by 1 March, and then the lawyers to file their Amended Reply and Answer by 15 March. On 13 March, the lawyers write to Lisa informing her that they intend to file their Amended Reply and Answer on 21 March. Lisa refuses to agree to the extension. On 16 March Lisa files a form 9 Application seeking Judgment against the lawyers. This is heard on 23 March. The Judge dismisses Lisa’s application because she has not used the proper procedure for dealing with any delay by the Plaintiffs, and that she is not entitled to judgment. Lisa is ordered to pay the lawyers’ costs (including barrister’s fees) which come to $9,000. This leads to Lisa being made bankrupt, and she is not able to continue her claim for negligence.

  8. If you feel that the conduct of the other parties’ lawyers has been improper, you can make a complaint to the Legal Services Commission (LSC) about that conduct. The LSC is the Queensland Government body established to regulate and supervise the conduct of lawyers in Queensland.
  9. The Queensland Law Society has produced a guide for solicitors in Queensland on dealing with self represented litigants. You can get a copy of that guide here.


Court proceedings - making progress

Court proceedings – making progress

While the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR) aim for a quick and speedy resolution of civil cases, this does not always happen for a variety of reasons.

This factsheet is designed to outline some of the procedures under the UCPR that you may be able to use to progress a matter.

If your matter is on the Supervised Case List or the Caseflow Management List, then your matter will be subject to regular hearings and to directions to progress it. See our factsheet Court supervision of cases for more information.

Otherwise, there are a number of other options that you might like to consider:

  1. If the other party has not complied with a particular step, you can send a rule 444 letter.
  2. If the matter is ready for trial, you can send a request for trial date.

Rule 444 letters

You use a rule 444 letter if:

  • You are seeking further and better particulars of a pleading under rule 161;
  • You want to seek directions from the court for the progression of the matter under Chapter 10 Part 1 of the UCPR;
  • The other party has not been complying with the UCPR and you want to seek orders to deal with that non-compliance under Chapter 10 Part 2 of the UCPR; or
  • The other party has not complied with an order or direction of the court.

For example, you could use a rule 444 letter if:

  1. The other party has not given you their list of documents, and the pleadings have closed;
  2. The other party has not returned a request for trial date; or
  3. The other party is in breach of a court order.

Writing a rule 444 letter

Below is a template of a rule 444 letter:

Dear [insert name]
[Case name]
Court File No.
This letter is written pursuant to Rule 444 and Chapter 11, Part 8 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR).
Relevant facts
[Chronological outline of facts relevant to proposed application.]
[PARTY NAME’S] Complaint
[Refer to rules, order not complied with.]
Intended relief
[Relief intended to be sought if the problem is not rectified. It should be the same as the orders that will be sought in the application to be filed. Eg: That the Plaintiff provide a list of documents within fourteen days; or that the Defence be struck out and the Defendent file an Amended Defence within twenty-one days.]
Why the [PARTY NAME] should have the relief
[Set out why you are entitled to relief if the complaint not rectified. Eg: Rule 162(1)(a) of the UCPR empowers the court to strike out a particular if it has a tendency to prejudice or delay a fair trial of the proceeding; or Rule 5 of the UCPR provides that the parties undertake to the court to proceed expeditiously and without delay to progress a proceeding.]
Time for a response
[At least 3 business days after date of the letter.]

Under the UCPR you can allow as little as three business days for the other party to respond, although allowing a lengthier period of two weeks can be better.

By the end of that period, you should have received a Rule 444 letter from the other party, either complying with the issue that you identified, or explaining why they believe that you are not entitled to the relief.

If you do not agree with the rule 444 letter, you can then bring an application to the court.

Completing your application documents

You will find the court forms on the courts website.

You will need a Form 9 Application, which should reflect the “relief sought” that you outlined in your rule 444 letter, and an affidavit (Form 46).

To this affidavit, you should exhibit a copy of your rule 444 letter and of the other party’s response.

When you file your documents, the court will give you a hearing date.


Serving court documents

Serving court documents

This factsheet contains information about serving court documents on the other party in cases in the Magistrates, District and Supreme Courts of Queensland.

The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR) contain a number of prescribed forms. You can find templates of these forms on the Queensland Courts Website.

Serving court documents

Service means giving the other party a copy of the court documents.

Personal service

In the District and Supreme Courts, documents that start a court proceeding (a Claim or an Originating Application) should generally be personally served on the other party.

When serving documents personally, you should ask the defendant their name.

If they refuse to accept the documents, it is acceptable to leave the documents in their presence after telling the defendant what the documents are (rule 106(2) of UCPR)

Example: You have filed a Claim and Statement of Claim against Jim Jones in the Supreme Court. You know Jim’s home address and that he is at home until 10.00 am in the morning. So at 9.00 am, you knock on Jim’s front door with the originating process in your hand. Jim answers the front door, and even though you recognise him, you say:
“Are you Jim Jones?” to which Jim replies “Yes, I am.”
You can then hand Jim the originating process – service is complete!
Say you start to hand the originating process to Jim but he steps back and moves to close the front door – he knows what the documents are and wants to avoid being served. You can say,
“This is a claim brought against you in the Supreme Court.”
You can then simply leave the originating process on the ground (or somewhere reasonable) at Jim’s front door.

In the Magistrates Court you can serve the other party the documents by leaving them with an adult who appears to reside at that address (rule 111 and rule 112 UCPR).

If before any court proceeding, the parties to a court case have made a contract, then that contract may state how the parties are to serve each other in the event of any court proceedings (rule 119 UCPR)

Mortgages, leases and most commercial contracts will contain such a clause. In such a case, personal service may not be necessary if the contract is complied with.

You should note that if you serve documents after 4 pm, then the person served is deemed to have been served on the next day (rule 103 UCPR). You cannot serve a person on Christmas or Good Friday unless a court order permits you to (rule 101 UCPR)

Corporations

A company can be served by posting the documents to the company’s registered office (section 109X Corporations Act 2001) or by leaving them at that address. To find the company’s registered office, you may need to do a search of ASIC’s company register (there is a fee for doing this search).

If an administrator or liquidator has been appointed, the company should be served by sending it to the administrator or liquidator.

Service of other documents

Parties to court proceedings notify the court of their “address for service” in a number of different ways:

  • When a plaintiff commences proceedings, the address for service will appear on the claim.
  • A defendant filing a Notice of Intention to Defend places their address for service in the Notice of Intention to Defend.
  • An originating application contains an applicant’s address for service
  • The respondent to an originating application by filing a notice of address for service
  • A party can also file a Change of Address for Service (form 90) or a Notice that Party is Acting in Person (form 92).

It is important that you keep your address for service up to date.

Once an address for service has been given, documents can be served by posting, emailing, faxing, or leaving those documents at the address for service.

When you are serving court documents you should serve a sealed copy. If you have finalised the document by its due date, but you have not yet had it sealed by the court, you should email or fax an unsealed (but signed and completed) copy of the document, and tell the other party that you will be filing that document in the court as soon as possible and that you will send them a sealed copy as soon as possible.

Substituted service

If you cannot find the other party then you may need to make an application to the court for an order for substituted service under rule 116 of the UCPR.

To obtain such an order, you need to convince the court that it is impracticable to serve the other party in accordance with the rules and that the way (or ways) you are proposing are likely to bring the case to the attention of the other party: Kendell v Sweeney [2002] QSC 404.

Typical orders might involve bringing the court documents to the other party’s attention by:

  1. Emailing them.
  2. Placing an advertisement of the proceedings in a newspaper where it might come to their attention.
  3. Leaving a copy of the court documents at the other party’s last known address or place of business.
  4. Serving the documents on the other party’s close family members.

Serving the documents on the other party’s close family members. Sometimes a search of either the electoral roll, the Land Titles Registry, telephone directories and social networking websites can be of assistance in locating a party.

In addition to making an order allowing substituted service, the court can also state when service on the other party will be deemed to have taken place. This can become important if you are serving a claim, and you might need to apply for default judgment.


Disclosure - practice and procedure

Disclosure – practice and procedure

When do I use this factsheet?

Once the pleadings (i.e. Statement of Claim, Defence (and Counterclaim), Reply (and Answer)) have been completed, or when the court orders, the parties must disclose the documents they intend to rely on.

Disclosure is outlined in Chapter 7, Part 1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR)

What is disclosure?

Disclosure is the delivery or production of documents by a party to a case to the other parties in the case (rule 210).

Disclosure is intended to prevent surprise at the trial, inform the parties of the issues to be disputed at the trial, and to assist the parties to resolve disputes of fact.

There are three main steps in the disclosure process:

  1. Serving a list of documents on the other party;
  2. Offering inspection of your disclosed documents to the other party; and/or
  3. Providing copies of your disclosed documents to the other party.

Who has to disclose?

In proceedings started by Claim, all parties to the court proceeding must perform disclosure (rule 209(1)(a)).

In proceedings started by Originating Application, disclosure only take place if the court orders it (rule 209(1)(c)).

When must disclosure take place?

Generally disclosure must take place within 28 days of the close of pleadings (rule 214(2)(c)).

The close of pleadings occurs:

  • When a pleading (usually a Reply) is served after a Defence or an answer to Counterclaim.
  • If the Defence is the final pleading in the matter, 14 days after the Defence is filed (rule 169).

The duty of disclosure continues throughout the entire court proceeding. Each time a relevant document comes into your possession or under your control, you need to disclose this to the other party within seven days (rule 214(2)(e)).

As a result you may have a list of documents, a supplementary list of documents, a further supplementary list of documents, etc.

In other cases disclosure must take place:

  1. any time before the close of pleadings if disclosure is ordered by the court (rule 214(2)(a));
  2. within 28 days after a summary decision by the court if the proceeding is not entirely finalised (rule 214(2)(b));.and
  3. when any further pleading or amended pleading is delivered (rule 214(2)(d)).

You must deliver a copy of a document requested in writing by another party within 28 days of the request (rule 214(2)(f)).

What do I have to disclose?

You must disclose all documents:

  • in your possession or under your control; and
  • that are directly relevant to an allegation in issue in the pleadings (rule 211).

Documents are not just paper with writing on them. A document includes:

  • any paper or other material on which there is writing;
  • any paper or other material on which there are marks, figures, symbols or perforations; and
  • any disc, tape or other article or any material from which sounds, images, writings or messages are capable of being produced or reproduced (section 36 Acts Interpretation Act 1954).

A document is in your possession or under your control if:

  • you possess it, that is you actually physically have the document;
  • the document is in your possession but not owned by you;
  • you are able to exercise direction over it (e.g. documents held by someone else on your behalf); and/or
  • in some cases, you are able to access the document from a government department.

If you only hold a copy of a document you should disclose the copy.

A document is directly relevant to an issue in the proceeding if it tends to prove or disprove an allegation in the pleadings.

The following documents must be disclosed if the other party asks for them:

  • documents relating only to damages (rule 221); and
  • documents mentioned in the pleadings, particulars or in affidavits (rule 222).

What about disclosing groups or classes of documents?

A group or class of documents includes several documents that are of the same type and can be disclosed as a group rather than as individual documents (e.g., Annual Reports from 2000 to 2010, correspondence between plaintiff’s solicitors and defendant’s solicitors from 1 November 2006.

Are there documents I don’t have to disclose?

You don’t have to disclose:

  • privileged documents;
  • documents relevant only to credit or credibility of a party; or
  • additional copies of documents already disclosed – if it is reasonable to suppose the additional copy contains no change, obliteration or other mark or feature likely to affect the outcome of the court proceeding (rule 212).

A document is privileged if it falls within one of these grounds:

  • legal professional privilege: Communications to obtain confidential legal advice and documents prepared for use in existing or anticipated litigation such as correspondence between a party * to the court proceeding and their solicitor and/or barrister;
  • without prejudice communications: Express or implied admissions or offers made during settlement negotiations that fail to produce a settlement;
  • self-incrimination: Documents that would disclose self-incriminatory material (not for companies or incorporated associations);
  • forfeitures and penalties: Evidence in support of a forfeiture or a penalty against you;
  • oppression: When a request for a massive amount of information outweighs the benefits to be derived from it; and
  • public interest: Information collected in the course of public duties or public administration.

Privileged documents do not include:

  • expert reports; and
  • a document consisting of a statement of an expert.

A party can challenge the other party’s claim of privilege by requiring the other party to file and serve an affidavit stating the basis of the claim within 7 days (rule 213).

What about documents with both relevant and irrelevant material?

As a general rule you should disclose entire copies of documents. Sometimes sensitive but irrelevant information contained within a document can be “redacted” (that is the sensitive information is removed by ruling a thick line through it). However it must be apparent to the other parties and the court that the material that has been redacted is irrelevant.

How do I perform disclosure?

Disclosure is performed by:

  1. giving to the other party a list of documents under rule 211; or
  2. giving to the other party copies of the documents in the list of documents (other than the privileged documents) when the other party requests copies (rule 214).

However, disclosure may also be performed by an inspection of the documents that need to be disclosed if:

  • it is not convenient for a party to deliver a list of documents and copies of documents because of the number, size, quantity or volume of the documents (rule 216); or
  • a party requests another party to produce for inspection specific original documents from the party’s list of documents (rules 215 and 216).

Do I have to pay for disclosure?

When the parties to an action have lawyers, the lawyers will often agree that each party will pay the photocopying expenses of the other party.

Under the UCPR, it is the responsibility of the party disclosing a document to:

  1. provide a copy of that document to the other party; or
  2. make the original document available for inspection, and to provide facilities for the making of a copy of those documents

without charge to the other party.

What happens if disclosure does not take place?

If you do not disclose a document, you:

  • must not tender the document, or adduce evidence of its contents, at the trial without the permission (leave) of the court;
  • may be liable to contempt for not disclosing the document; and
  • may be ordered to pay the costs or a part of the costs of the court proceeding (rule 225).

If the other party does not disclose a document, you may apply to the court for:

  • an order staying or dismissing all or part of the court proceeding;
  • judgment or another order against the party required to disclose the document; or
  • an order that the document be disclosed in the way and within the time stated in the order (rule 225).

If the court is satisfied that:

  • there are special circumstances and the interests of justice require it; or
  • there is an objective likelihood that a party has not complied with the duty of disclosure or a document or group of documents exists or existed and has passed out of the possession or control of a party (rule 223),

the court may order a party to:

  • deliver to the other party a copy of a document or group of documents; or
  • produce the document or group of documents for inspection by the other party; or
  • file and serve on another party an affidavit stating that a specified document or group of documents does not exist or has never existed or the circumstances in which a specified document or group of documents ceased to exist or passed out of the possession or control of the party.

In other cases, the court may order a party to:

  • deliver, produce or inspect a document or group of documents;
  • not deliver, produce or inspect a document or group of documents;
  • defer the delivery, production or inspection of documents (rule 223); or
  • be relieved of the duty of disclosure (rule 224).

Do disclosed documents need to be produced at trial?

Disclosed documents must be produced at the trial if:

  • notice to produce the documents has been given; and
  • the party is asked to produce the documents at the trial (rule 227(1)).

If you tender a disclosed document at trial, the other party is entitled to rely on that document (rule 227(2)).

What if someone else has the documents?

The UCPR allows you to obtain documents from someone who is not a party to the proceedings through “non party disclosure.”

If you can get these documents in some other way, e.g. if the documents belong to you, you should not use the non party disclosure process (rule 243(1)(c)).

You need to (1) identify the allegations in the pleadings that the documents you want relate to, and (2) identify what documents you want to obtain.

You then need to complete a notice of non party disclosure, Form 21. You can find this form on the Court’s website.

You will be called the applicant. The non-party you are seeking documents from is called the respondent.

You should then file the original and at least two copies of the form in the registry.

Rules 243 and 244 require you to serve a sealed copy of the Form 21 notice on the following within three months of the date of issue:

  1. any person, except for a party, that the notice seeks information about (rule 244(1)(a));
  2. the owner of the document (if the respondent is not the owner of the document (rule 244(1)(b)); and
  3. the respondent. You should serve the respondent after you have served the other persons required to be served (rule 243(2)).

The notice must be served in the same way as a claim (rule 243(1)(e)). It should be either personally served or in the case of a company served by posting it to the registered office of the company (section 109X Corporations Act 2001).

The respondent or another person served with a notice of non-party disclosure has seven days from when they are served to serve a written objection to producing the documents listed (rule 245(1)). Another person affected by the notices who wants to object needs the leave of the court to do so (rule 245(2)).

A notice can be objected to on the following grounds:

  1. the expense and inconvenience to the respondent of complying with the request (if the respondent is objecting) (rule 245(4)(a));
  2. lack of relevance (rule 245(4)(b));
  3. that the documents are not sufficiently particularised (i.e. identified) (rule 245(4)(c));
  4. privilege (rule 245(4)(d));
  5. confidentiality (rule 245(4)(e));
  6. the effect disclosure would have on another person (rule 245(4)(f)); and/or
  7. if the objector was not served with the notice (and was required to be served), the failure to serve the notice (rule 245(4)(g)).

If an objection is served, the notice is stayed (rule 246). The applicant then has seven days in which to apply to the court for a decision about the notice (rule 247).

Can disclosure take place electronically?

In cases where there are more than 500 documents to disclose the courts encourage the parties to conduct disclosure electronically. Practice Direction 8 of 2004 Electronic Management of Documents deals with preparing a document protocol.


Drafting an outline of argument or submissions

Drafting an outline of argument or submissions

If you are in a civil matter in the Queensland Court of Appeal or the District Court, or in some matters in the Magistrates Court, you will have to file an Outline of Argument.

Even if it is not required, it is common practice for lawyers attending court hearings to give the court a summary of their argument. In fact, it can be a good way of:

  1. helping you to organise your thoughts ahead of the court hearing. This can be invaluable in calming your nerves. The better prepared you are, the easier your court appearance will be; and
  2. putting your arguments in a clear straightforward way to the judge.

Various court practice directions deal with outlines of argument:

  1. District Court Practice Direction 7 of 2020 requires the parties to appeals in the District Court to prepare and file an Outline of Argument.
  2. Supreme Court Practice Direction 12 of 22 require the legal representatives of parties in interlocutory applications to file an Outline of Argument, limited to six pages.
  3. Magistrates Court Practice Direction 5 of 2024 provides for parties to applications, who wish to provide an outline of argument, to do so, with such outlines usually being limited to six pages.

Some tips for drafting an outline of argument

  1. Don’t make the Outline of Argument too long or repetitive. If your argument is expressed clearly and makes sense, then repeating it won’t make it more persuasive. If your argument is poorly set out, repeating it won’t help you. Make your point once, then move on to the next issue.
  2. There isn’t a form under the UCPR for an Outline of Argument, but you can adapt the basic format of a court document (e.g. the header) to create your outline of argument.
  3. Use headings. For example:
    1. Why should leave to appeal be granted? If you need the leave of the court, set out firstly why you are seeking leave to appeal, identifying the errors of law that you are relying on.
    2. If you don’t need leave, your first heading should be “What this appeal is about”; an introductory paragraph that sets out very basically what the case is about.
    3. Background; you should just include a couple of paragraphs setting out the key background facts of the case.
    4. Grounds of appeal; you should then use separate headings to discuss each of your ground of appeal first stating the law relating to that issue, then a separate paragraph applying the law to the facts of your case.
    5. Orders sought; you should include a heading where you set out what outcome you want from the court.

An outline for an interlocutory hearing might use the following headers:

What is this hearing about?
Background facts
Issues
Orders sought
  1. Your Outline of Argument should contain the legal arguments you are relying on, not your evidence.
  2. Your Outline of Argument should just be an outline or summary of your argument.
  3. Consider using a chronology of the key facts.
  4. Comply with the Practice Directions about Outlines of Argument in the court that you are appearing in.
  5. If you are using an Outline of Argument, bring two copies for the court, one for each of the other parties and one for yourself.
  6. Consider serving the Outline of Argument on the other party before the hearing.
  7. Keep the outline short and to the point.
  8. Use short paragraphs.
  9. Avoid lengthy quotations.

Current as at 14 January 2025.